The five most-shocking NCAA tournament first-round upsets

For the 14th consecutive year, at least one No. 4 regional seed knocked off a No. 1 seed. Randy Johnson ranks his top five upsets.

April 1, 2019 at 1:03PM
American International College players celebrated a goal during the second period of an NCAA men's Division I hockey tournament regional semifinal against St. Cloud State on Friday.
American International College players celebrated a goal during the second period of an NCAA men’s Division I hockey tournament regional semifinal against St. Cloud State on Friday. (St. Cloud Times via Associated Press/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
American International College players celebrate a goal during the second period of an NCAA men's Division I hockey tournament regional semifinal against St. Cloud State Friday, March 29, 2019, in Fargo, N.D. (Dave Schwarz/St. Cloud Times via AP)
(Associated Press/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Two No. 1 regional seeds – St. Cloud State and Minnesota State – suffered first-round NCAA tournament losses over the weekend, joining a growing club. This tournament marked the 14th consecutive year that a No. 1 regional seed lost to a No. 4. Here is one man's view of the biggest upsets since the tournament went to 16 teams in 2003:

5. 2009 Midwest Regional, Bemidji State 5, No. 2 overall Notre Dame 1: The Beavers carried an 18-15-1 record into Grand Rapids, Mich., and manhandled the 31-5-3 Fighting Irish as Tyler Scofield had two goals and an assist. A day later, Bemidji State beat Cornell 4-1 to secure its only Frozen Four berth.

4. 2010 East Regional, Rochester Institute of Technology 2, No. 2 overall Denver 1: The Tigers pulled off the upset of the WCHA regular-season champion Pioneers in Albany, N.Y., on the strength of 39 saves by Jared DeMichiel. RIT would beat New Hampshire 6-2 to make the Frozen Four.

3. 2015 Midwest Regional, RIT 2, No. 1 overall Minnesota State 1: The Tigers carried a 19-14-5 record into the game in South Bend against the Mavericks (29-7-3). Josh Mitchell scored the winner with 5:51 left in the third period on a goal that initially was waved off because of goaltender interference before being ruled good on a video review. To this day, that controversial call still angers Mavericks fans.

2. 2019 West Regional, American International 2, No. 1 overall St. Cloud State 1: For the second consecutive year, the Huskies were the No. 1 overall seed and were ousted by the Atlantic Hockey tournament champion. The Yellow Jackets followed Air Force's 2018 lead by dictating play against the talented and deep Huskies (30-5-3) for most of the game.

1. 2006 West Regional, Holy Cross 4, No. 2 overall Minnesota 3 (OT): Though this isn't the biggest upset by PairWise ranking or seed – Wisconsin was the No. 1 overall seed, not the Gophers – Minnesota's stunning loss in Grand Forks, N.D., lives on. The Gophers were WCHA regular-season champs and only three years removed from back-to-back NCAA championships. Thirteen years later, you'll still see North Dakota fans wearing Holy Cross sweaters to tease Gophers fans.

about the writer

about the writer

Randy Johnson

College football reporter

Randy Johnson covers University of Minnesota football and college football for the Minnesota Star Tribune, along with Gophers hockey and the Wild.

See Moreicon

More from Wild

card image

Golden Knights coach Bruce Cassidy broke up his top line and the moves paid off when Ivan Barbashev scored the game-winner.

card image