Teen spared prison for threatening to shoot Gustavus Adolphus student before stealing her car

The judge opted for a year in jail for Tayvius Martin, who still has a theft charge pending tied to stealing money from a gas station safe.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
August 25, 2025 at 9:38PM
Gustavus Adolphus College in St. Peter, MN. Gustavus Adolphus College was hit by a tornado in 1998 destroying 2,000 trees and 80 percent of the windows on campus buildings.
Charges say the 21-year-old student had just parked her car in Lot A on the private school’s campus in St. Peter, Minn., and was walking to her dormitory when a masked man ordered her to hand over her vehicle’s keys or be shot in the head. (Carlos Gonzalez/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

A teenager was spared prison Monday and given a one-year jail term for ambushing a Gustavus Adolphus College student in a campus parking lot late at night and threatening to shoot her in the head before he stole her car.

Tayvius Sorgatz Martin, 19, of Rochester, was sentenced in Nicollet County District Court after pleading guilty to first-degree carjacking in connection with the brandishing what his victim feared was an assault-style rifle while stealing her car about 2:45 a.m. on Sept. 14, 2024.

Over the objections of the County Attorney’s Office, Judge Paul Gunderson set aside a sentence of slightly more than six years and opted for the year in jail. With credit for time in jail since his arrest, Martin has about 4½ months left to serve.

Martin’s sentence also includes 240 hours of ”sentence to serve,” which often means being part of a supervised work crew, and five years of probation.

Defense attorney Eric Olson argued in a court filing last year for Martin to receive leniency for various reasons, among them a “neglectful, abusive and chaotic” first eight years of life.

James Dunn, chief deputy for the County Attorney’s Office, told the Minnesota Star Tribune that Gunderson also took into account “Mr. Martin’s age and lack of brain development due to his youth, that Mr. Martin was remorseful for his actions, that he was cooperative in court and took responsibility for his actions and that he had strong familial and community supports.”

Martin still has a theft case pending in Olmsted County alleging he stole $540 from the safe of a Circle K gas station in Rochester, where he’s been living in a group home for young people.

His record in juvenile court includes allegations that he smashed in the window of a car in Cottage Grove and drove off, vehicle theft in Stearns County and felony damage to property in Hennepin County.

According to the charges:

The 21-year-old student had just parked her car in Lot A on the private school’s campus in St. Peter, Minn., and was walking to her dormitory when a masked man ordered her to hand over her vehicle’s keys or be shot in the head.

The woman told police that her assailant was holding what appeared to her to be an AR-style rifle across the front of his body. The assailant then drove off in her car, and the student ran to her dormitory and contacted police.

Later that day, police alerted counterparts in Plymouth that the car had been spotted in the west metro suburb. Police saw the car and arrested Martin.

Martin’s parents told police that their son owns an AR-style airsoft rifle, a weapon that is a replica of a lethal firearm but can cause no more than minor injuries.

about the writer

about the writer

Paul Walsh

Reporter

Paul Walsh is a general assignment reporter at the Minnesota Star Tribune. He wants your news tips, especially in and near Minnesota.

See Moreicon