Super Bowl argument: Did Patriots defense make game beautiful or just plain ugly?

You can look at New England's 13-3 Super Bowl victory over the rams as an exercise in beautiful defense or ugly because of the lack of offense. Staff writers Mark Craig and Michael Rand battle over that question.

February 4, 2019 at 9:34PM
The Patriots defense pushed Rams quarterback Jared Goff out of bounds (left); the Rams defense stopped New England's Cordarrelle Patterson.
The Patriots defense pushed Rams quarterback Jared Goff out of bounds (left); the Rams defense stopped New England's Cordarrelle Patterson. (Howard Sinker/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Early Monday morning, the Star Tribune's Michael Rand posted this on his RandBall blog:

style="font-size: 100%;">More than great defense, the game contained lousy offense. Tom Brady threw a terrible pass on his first drive interception. Jared Goff was a nightmare almost the whole game, and what proved to be the game-clinching interception was a poorly thrown ball.

Todd Gurley continued to be a mystery. The MVP was a possession receiver. Julian Edelman was good, but it is fitting that the game's best offensive player is most notable for keeping the chains moving.

There wasn't a single "Wow!" moment or whiff of controversy.

Soon after, NFL writer Mark Craig countered in his analysis for Tuesday's print edition of the Star Tribune:

A Patriots team immune to the NFL's laws of parity kept doing what they weren't supposed to do. They finished the season beating the top two scoring teams — Kansas City (35.3) and the Rams (32.9) — while shutting both of them out in the first half.

"It's 11 guys, man," safety Devin McCourty said. "There was no God that did it all. It was 11 guys all day."

With today's rule book tilted heavily in favor of the offense, the Super Bowl came down to defense. Had the Rams made a few more plays or found an answer for game MVP Julian Edelman, we'd be talking about 71-year-old defensive coordinator Wade Phillips pitching his second Super Bowl masterpiece with a second team in four seasons.

You can read the full RandBall blog post here and Craig's analysis here.

about the writer

about the writer

Star Tribune

More from No Section

See More
FILE -- A rent deposit slot at an apartment complex in Tucker, Ga., on July 21, 2020. As an eviction crisis has seemed increasingly likely this summer, everyone in the housing market has made the same plea to Washington: Send money — lots of it — that would keep renters in their homes and landlords afloat. (Melissa Golden/The New York Times) ORG XMIT: XNYT58
Melissa Golden/The New York Times

It’s too soon to tell how much the immigration crackdown is to blame.