It is a narrative so simple it seems preordained, but so unexpected it seems like a fairytale.
The St. Thomas football team, in its inaugural Division I campaign, will travel to North Carolina on Saturday to face Davidson with a path to the Pioneer League title hanging in the balance.
That the Tommies (5-2 overall, 4-1 conference) have the league's best scoring defense (15.3 points allowed per game) and the Wildcats (6-1, 5-0) have the league's best scoring offense (37.6 points per game) only adds to the charm.
Wildcats coach Scott Abell has spent four seasons building a Pioneer League powerhouse at Davidson but knows about the Tommies and coach Glenn Caruso from his days coaching Division III Washington & Lee.
"They certainly are, if not the best defense in the league, one of the best defenses in the league, and the numbers would tell you they are the best defense," Abell said. "They get to the football, they're physical, they are very well coached. I have nothing but praise for what they do defensively."
If there is an answer for St. Thomas' surprising success this season, it starts with that defense.
More directly, it starts with giving up 44 points to Northern Iowa in the Tommies' second game of the season.
The boxscore looked like a thrashing, a 44-3 loss that seemed to exemplify all the difficulties St. Thomas would face in making the unprecedented transition from Division III to Division I football.