Minutes after the two not-guilty verdicts were read in Lance J. Hartwig's trial on Thursday, members of the jury burst into a conference room to laugh, cry, celebrate and embrace the defendant.
Hartwig, 28, was accused of ditching a .38-caliber Taurus revolver that his best buddy, Anton Burnes, allegedly used to shoot Kevin Dunn in an alleyway in St. Paul's Frogtown neighborhood on May 31, 2008. Hartwig maintained all along that he never had the gun.
"I believe you, I really believe you," juror Nick Stueber, 20, said as he hugged Hartwig. "Until closing arguments, I wasn't sure. Then it just came. It just came."
The facts just didn't add up. There were too many inconsistencies, jurors said.
"It's such a good feeling to be able to show that if things are improbable, a jury will listen," Hartwig's attorney, Ryan Pacyga said.
Hartwig was reluctant to comment, but did say, "Mr. Pacyga definitely seeks justice and he found it for me and I'm forever grateful, forever."
This was Hartwig's second trial on charges of accomplice after the fact to second-degree intentional murder and possession of a firearm by an ineligible person. The jury in his trial in May deadlocked, and District Judge Rosanne Nathanson declared a mistrial.
Hartwig, Burnes and others had been drinking the night of May 30-31, 2008, at Willard's Bar at Grotto Street and Thomas Avenue. Dunn was there, too, celebrating his 28th birthday.