The Twins made a big investment in second baseman Tsuyoshi Nishioka over the offseason, paying $5.3 million just for the rights to negotiate with him, then giving the Japanese infielder a $9.25 million contract.
But now their biggest offseason acquisition will be sidelined for possibly up to two months because of a broken leg suffered Thursday, when Yankees right fielder Nick Swisher ran into Nishioka trying to break up a potential double play during New York's 4-3 victory over the Twins at Yankee Stadium. The injury leaves some question marks in the middle of the Twins infield, with Alexi Casilla still not a proven everyday player at shortstop.
A year ago, the shortstop and second base positions were set at this point with the trade for shortstop J.J. Hardy from Milwaukee and the signing of veteran free-agent second baseman Orlando Hudson. They also had longtime reserve Nick Punto to fill in as needed, as he had done capably throughout his Twins career.
But Hudson was allowed to leave as a free agent after the season, signing with San Diego. Hardy was traded to Baltimore to help clear the way for Nishioka's arrival, and Punto's $5 million option was not picked up, and he signed for St. Louis for a $750,000 deal. Punto underwent surgery for a sports hernia in February, and the Cardinals have not set a date for when he will be able to return.
However, a big plus for the Twins at this point is that at least the corner infield positions seem to be solidified. Last year, first baseman Justin Morneau was having an MVP-type season before suffering a concussion that ended his season in July after only 81 games. He was hitting .345 with 18 home runs and 56 RBI at the time. Then, over the second half of the season, rookie call-up Danny Valencia emerged as an outstanding third baseman at the plate and in the field. He hit .311 and with seven home runs and 40 RBI, with all but three RBI coming after the All-Star break.
The Twins essentially had each for only half of 2010, when they won the AL Central by six games. If Morneau and Valencia can stay healthy -- and if Morneau can hit like he did before he left the lineup and if Valencia can hit like he did after he joined it -- the Twins could overcome the second base and shortstop question marks.
Bud Grant's theory that athletic ability is important but durability is just as or more important has followed the Twins in recent years. Last season, they led the major leagues with 13 players spending time on the disabled list, including key players such as Morneau.
The injury to Nishioka is a terrible blow because the Twins expected so much from him, and they don't have anybody with equal ability and potential to replace him.