Rochester schools won't add Eid to calendar — for now

District officials say they need more time to study how adding additional holidays would impact student learning.

December 14, 2022 at 5:12PM
The Rochester Public Schools Board in June 2022. (Trey Mewes, Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

ROCHESTER – Despite lengthy discussions, schools in this community won't add Eid al-Fitr or other religious holidays to the district calendar next year.

The Rochester Public Schools Board on Tuesday finalized the district's 2023-2024 calendar, which didn't include Eid. School officials debated adding the Muslim holiday to account for the sizable Muslim student population in Rochester, but ultimately decided to table the issue to provide more in-class time.

"It's a conversation that's going to continue," board chair Jean Marvin said.

Superintendent Kent Pekel said Rochester is reviewing the best ways to use school time to support students as part of its ongoing strategic planning process. The 2023-2024 calendar starts and ends school a week earlier than normal as classes begin Aug. 29 for middle and high schoolers.

District officials are also discussing whether to add more religious holidays in addition to Eid to the calendar. The issue will likely come up as the board sets the 2024-2025 calendar next year.

Holidays like Eid, which is scheduled according to the lunar calendar, can make classroom planning difficult. Students who celebrate religious holidays can be excused from class, but Pekel said the district needs to weigh how added holidays impact student learning.

"Even if you're taking the day off, if it's not on the celebration, are we fully recognizing that?" Pekel said.

Rochester's decision comes as other districts across the state add Eid and Jewish holidays to school calendars. The St. Paul Public Schools Board on Tuesday added Eid, Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur to the 2023-2024 calendar. Four other districts — Minneapolis, Mankato, Hopkins and Moorhead — have already included Eid in their calendars.

At least 10% of the district's 17,600 or so students celebrate Eid, according to district officials.

The district is also considering changing school start times for elementary students after years of discussion.

Rochester schools in 2020 and 2021 moved start times to after 8 a.m. to help middle and high school students learn better, but that forced elementary schools to start between 9:25 and 9:30 a.m. due to busing schedules. The move has been criticized by elementary staff and parents.

Rochester has spent months discussing how best to adjust class times for elementary schools, and the district recently hired Minneapolis-based Center for Effective School Operations to further study the issue.

about the writer

about the writer

Trey Mewes

Rochester reporter

Trey Mewes is a reporter based in Rochester for the Star Tribune. Sign up to receive the Rochester Now newsletter.

See Moreicon