Review: 'The Wolf Border,' by Sarah Hall; exploring limits of freedom, wildness

FICTION: A pregnant zoologist navigates the boundaries of intimacy while overseeing a project to reintegrate the gray wolf into northern England.

For the Minnesota Star Tribune
June 21, 2015 at 11:40AM
This undated image provided by Montana Fish Wildlife and Parks shows a wolf in Montana. Facing mounting pressure from Congress, wildlife advocates and the U.S. Department of Interior on Friday March 18, 2011 reached an agreement to lift gray wolf protections in Montana and Idaho and allow hunting of the predators to resume.(AP Photo/Montana Fish Wildlife and Parks) ORG XMIT: MIN2013072918003984
This undated image provided by Montana Fish Wildlife and Parks shows a wolf in Montana. Facing mounting pressure from Congress, wildlife advocates and the U.S. Department of Interior on Friday March 18, 2011 reached an agreement to lift gray wolf protections in Montana and Idaho and allow hunting of the predators to resume.(AP Photo/Montana Fish Wildlife and Parks) ORG XMIT: MIN2013072918003984 (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Sarah Hall's ruminative fifth novel, "The Wolf Border," follows Rachel Caine, an estranged zoologist, as she navigates the precarious boundaries of intimacy. At the request of Thomas Pennington, the Earl of Annerdale, Rachel flies to her home village off the northwest coast of England. The earl wants to reintegrate the gray wolf, a species that's been absent from the region for hundreds of years.

Wavering at his offer to make her project manager, she visits her dying mother, Binny, a feisty, "self-declared, red-blooded sensualist." Soon after Rachel returns to Idaho, Binny commits suicide, and, after a one-night stand with her co-worker, Rachel becomes pregnant.

She harbors the secret, believing "romance fails because it is never supposed to work, past the act itself, the momentum of lust." After skipping Binny's funeral, Rachel is fueled by a sudden urge to reconcile with her half-brother, Lawrence, so she accepts the earl's offer.

Rachel contemplates an abortion, recalling the discombobulation of her own childhood. The project distracts her, and she enters a kind of limbo. Her life runs parallel with the wolves' reintegration: The wolves mate and relearn to hunt; she slowly makes herself vulnerable to the wildness of human relationships. She has a casual, mutually respectful romance with a veterinarian, Alexander. She decides to keep the baby, and a lot of page time is taken up with vivid snapshots of pregnancy and early infancy.

Hall's ever-present penchant for painting the landscape is in full force here, the lyricism reminiscent of her descriptions of the mist-soaked English seaside town of her second novel, "The Electric Michelangelo": "The leaves are sibilant in the breeze, and the head of the moon looms on the horizon like an alien silo." These moments signal the changing of seasons, the inevitable evolution of all things living.

Like Rachel, the book keeps the reader at a distance. Her sudden motive to reconcile with Lawrence is a tad blurry. How did Rachel become the cold half-prodigal she is? Rather than penetrate Rachel's interior, Hall seems to want us to understand Rachel via the wolves' reintegration, which has a surprising and satisfying end.

Where does freedom end and wildness begin? Self-preservation and intimacy? Sex and commitment? These are the gray borders Hall inspects. Despite the subplots about political protests and Lawrence's addictions and unsavory groundskeepers, the real story is the one about one woman's coming to terms, not only with her family, but with her own untameable nature.

It's a quiet inner odyssey that eschews the conventional standard of plot and instead forges itself incrementally, in beautifully sculpted prose.

Josh Cook's fiction and reviews have appeared in the Iowa Review, Thirty-Two Magazine, the Millions and elsewhere.


Sarah Hall Photo by Richard Thwaites
Sarah Hall (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
"The Wolf Border," by Sarah Hall
"The Wolf Border," by Sarah Hall (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
BRIAN PETERSON • brianp@startribune.com APPLE VALLEY, MN - June, 8, 2011 ] An 8-year-old Mexican Gray Wolf escaped from a secondary enclosure (Not an exhibit!) at the Minnesota Zoo Wednesday morning, and spotted running on part of the Norther Trail before it was shot and Killed by zoo officials. (IN THIS PHOTO) One of the two remaining Mexican Gray Wolves on exhibit was a popular attraction after the excitement spread around the zoo grounds.
BRIAN PETERSON • brianp@startribune.com APPLE VALLEY, MN - June, 8, 2011 ] An 8-year-old Mexican Gray Wolf escaped from a secondary enclosure (Not an exhibit!) at the Minnesota Zoo Wednesday morning, and spotted running on part of the Norther Trail before it was shot and Killed by zoo officials. (IN THIS PHOTO) One of the two remaining Mexican Gray Wolves on exhibit was a popular attraction after the excitement spread around the zoo grounds. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

JOSH COOK