•••
The U.S. Supreme Court has now ruled, by a 6-3 majority, that a public high school coach at a school-sanctioned event — a football game — may go to the center of the field to pray his very Christian prayer (Nation & World, June 28). He may invite his players to join him. He is simply exercising his right to free speech.
Is it really this simple?
In a different setting, what happens when a leader-coach, teacher or principal — a believer in one faith or another — decides it's time for a prayer? S/he calls it a private act but invites others to join in. Imagine a public school in the Twin Cities. Imagine a fourth-grade class made up of children of different religions and the teacher wants to pray, aloud and in the classroom, a prayer grounded in his or her religion.
Any children of a faith different from the teacher's might be quite uncomfortable. If/when they don't conform, is the one kid who is different made to feel embarrassment or, worse, shame at not participating? At some point, this can feel coercive. I can only imagine the reaction from some members of our community if a Muslim teacher wanted to share a Muslim prayer and explain its context. Maybe even teach it so kids could join in. The phones of conservative legislators would be ringing off the hook. Not with praise.
There is a good reason why public schools should be off-limits for prayer and open manifestations of religious faith. That means all faiths. It is just not the place for a practice that really puts unfair pressure on kids. The court's action to sanction prayer in a public-school setting (yes, even a football field counts) can easily lead from the quaint notion of "voluntary" to "expected." A classroom teacher who invites kids to start the day with a rousing "Lord's Prayer," with an opt-out clause for those who don't want to join in, will only exacerbate rifts in our society. Nonetheless, those who love the ruling are ready to push any boundaries to impose their will on the rest of society. The court has opened that door.
Joshua Gruber, Minneapolis