The March 31 article "NCAA to phase in trans rules" tells us of plans to follow the International Olympic Committee's (IOC's) lead in "moving away from testosterone-based limits toward a system that doesn't presume transgender women have an advantage."
What is missing in this story and many like it is any attempt to look at what science tells us about the difference between male and female physical capabilities and the impact of medical transition on those capabilities. Emma Hilton, a researcher in developmental biology at the University of Manchester, Great Britain, and Tommy Lundberg, a physiologist at the Karolinska Institute, Sweden, performed a systematic review of the scientific literature addressing this topic in 2020 in an article titled "Transgender Women in the Female Category of Sport: Perspectives on Testosterone Suppression and Performance Advantage" (tinyurl.com/hilton-lundberg).
Hilton and Lundberg found that indeed, males do have a significant physical advantage over females in sports. The performance gap between males and females ranges from between 11 and 13% in the events of rowing, swimming and running to between 31 and 37% in weightlifting to more than 50% in the speed of baseball pitches. The gap is so great that 14-year-old males have broken the women's records in the 800- and 1,500-meter track events. These differences in physical ability are the reason women's sports were developed in the first place.
Hilton and Lundberg also looked at the available research on the impact of medical transition (i.e., testosterone suppression) on transwomen's physical capabilities. Research is sparse, but what is available shows that while testosterone suppression leads to modest losses in lean body mass, muscle area and strength, it brings trans women nowhere near the levels of biological females.
The IOC's previous standard of requiring trans women to suppress their testosterone levels for the 12 months prior to competition was not fair nor based in science. But that standard at least gave a slight nod to the reality that males have a physical advantage over females. Now the IOC and NCAA tell us they will not even presume that trans women have an advantage. They are demonstrating that they do not consider women's sports to be real sports deserving of a level playing field. There are only a few fields of endeavor where biological sex matters, and sport is one of them.
Susan Illg, St. Paul
MINNESOTA LEGISLATURE
Paid leave — insurance or government program?
A Minnesota Senate bill makes insurance companies administrators of "paid leave" benefits ("State GOP unveils family leave bill," March 22). The senators believe the insurance companies can administer it better than our government.
Consider that when insurance companies calculate their premium rates for a particular coverage, they first add their administrative costs and then the actual benefit cost paid to the recipient. They also estimate a nice profit.