•••
A June 29 letter writer ("Court starts the ball rolling") sets up a number of far-fetched straw men/women to knock down in an overreaction to the recent U.S. Supreme Court religion decision ("Court backs coach's prayer on field," June 28).
Justice Neil Gorsuch has it correct — that the First Amendment was not intended to suppress religious voices in the public sector, but that this practice has indeed become an operative model in recent years that needed addressing. You can "limit" it to the public school situation, but my experience is that to speak up overtly on the basis of one's faith in the public square has become pretty much verboten in our culture across the board. As if to speak of God and biblical principles as a basis to be considered in making a decision somehow violates the separation of church and state in any setting.
Freedom of the press and freedom of religion are linked in the First Amendment because they're both about the free intercourse of ideas in the public marketplace. Religious viewpoints — of whatever flavor — have a distinct place in the public conversation because overall they bring a well-thought-out set of ethical/moral principles — often inconvenient principles — to the conversation.
Does every "religious" person articulate these well, or use them well, instead of as a cover for other biases? Of course not. But the issues raised are often important, and often inconvenient. We on the "liberal" side of the faith were certainly inconvenient for those on the other side of the civil-rights arguments in the 1960s. And some on the right today raise inconvenient questions about a number of moral issues that people don't like to be reminded of either. Does either side get to embody those values in the "state?" In a democracy, only at the ballot box.
A person — a leader? a teacher? — expressing their faith in public may feel awkward. But I hardly think that it's going to "indoctrinate" anyone.
Then again, God does seem to reach out to people in lots of odds ways. Perhaps it's why C.S. Lewis once commented that a budding atheist needs to be careful — because God is very unscrupulous.