Readers Write (Sept. 18): Oil trains, Adrian Peterson, whistleblower, public vs. private schools

We need rail to move farm products, so let's build some pipelines to relieve traffic.

September 17, 2014 at 11:02PM
FILE - In this Nov. 6, 2013, file photo, a BNSF Railway train hauls crude oil near Wolf Point, Mont. The U.S. Department of Transportation ordered railroads last month to give state officials specifics on oil train routes and volumes so emergency responders can better prepare for accidents. North Dakota's State Emergency Response Commission unanimously voted to release the state's information Wednesday June 25, 2014. (AP Photo/Matthew Brown, File) ORG XMIT: MIN2014072519284756 ORG XMIT: MIN14072
FILE - In this Nov. 6, 2013, file photo, a BNSF Railway train hauls crude oil near Wolf Point, Mont. The U.S. Department of Transportation ordered railroads last month to give state officials specifics on oil train routes and volumes so emergency responders can better prepare for accidents. North Dakota's State Emergency Response Commission unanimously voted to release the state's information Wednesday June 25, 2014. (AP Photo/Matthew Brown, File) ORG XMIT: MIN2014072519284756 ORG XMIT: MIN1407251929591668 (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

First, the 100-car oil trains were a safety concern. Now they are overloading the rail system ("Minnesota farmers beg officials to fix rail problems," Sept. 14). Because the rail system is the only efficient way to move tons of agricultural production to market, the overloaded railroads are failing our farmers.

So when the politicians complain about rail service, they miss the point. What's needed is a multifaceted transportation system including pipelines connecting to North Dakota. Can everyone say Keystone XL and Sandpiper in unison?

STEPHEN JOHNSON, New Brighton
ADRIAN PETERSON

What we've learned about parenting skills

Parents like Adrian Peterson need to learn that harsh discipline doesn't work. Study after study conclusively prove hitting, whipping, slapping, switching, paddling, kicking, whooping, punching, spanking or belting a defenseless child may relieve a parent's frustration, but the child will have to be hit again because nothing has been learned to change behavior. Hitting has a long-term damaging impact on children and makes them more aggressive.

One of the best parent education programs in the United States is available in Minnesota, thanks to farsighted legislators 30-plus years ago. Every local school district has Early Childhood Family Education (ECFE). Millions of Minnesota moms and dads have learned basic principles of good parenting and gotten support from other parents in low-cost ECFE programs. The cycle of "I was hit and I turned out fine" ends by loving your child unconditionally, treating your child respectfully, learning positive discipline, modeling good behavior and adapting parenting to fit each child.

MARILYN MARTIN ROSSMANN, St. Paul

• • •

The resolution to the Adrian Peterson situation is simple. With a newly engaged parenting coach, he should address the media and begin a national discussion about abuse-free child rearing. If he would do that and pledge a year of his salary to child care and child abuse organizations, he would become the face and force for positive change. This is a huge opportunity. Let's give AP the chance for redemption — not consign him to the junk heap — and benefit children and families everywhere.

FRANK C. FEINBERG, St. Louis Park

• • •

I am disgusted by Patrick Reusse's support of Adrian Peterson ("Due process for AP is a good thing," Sept. 16). His call for "a full look at the facts" shows he ignored Peterson's reported admission that he beat his 4-year-old bloody with a stick. Peterson stated that he never intended to harm his son. What did he think would happen when he beat him with a stick? Reusse disgustingly cares more about the Vikings winning than a bloodied 4-year-old. And thanks to Jim Souhan, who had the morals to write in support of protecting the boy ("Audible on Peterson signals win-above-all mentality by Vikings," Sept. 16). What kind of society will we have if we won't protect children from this sick abuse?

LINDA POZNANOVIC, Blaine

• • •

I appreciated Jon Tevlin's effort to seek out experts in the field of child protection such as the Joel Bergstrom, communications director for the Greater Twin Cities Nursery ("Peterson case is a prism for views on race, culture, abuse," Sept 17). This is a very complex issue that impacts the lives of many people. Children do not benefit from being beaten. The people who beat them do deserve the opportunity to learn and change their ways.

What will we all take away from this event? I for one, want to use this opportunity to encourage all parents to re-examine their perspectives on the use of corporal punishment. It is not an effective technique, despite what you may think worked for you when your parents were trying to guide your behavior. Too often, it can lead to serious injuries and even death, despite the parent's intention to just teach the child a lesson. Now, what will the NFL and the many corporate sponsors take away from this experience? Will it be to make a bigger financial and values commitment to the prevention of child abuse? Or will they just be happy to make the right moves to lessen their connection to this unfortunate situation and carry on as usual?

MARTHA GERKEY, Stillwater
WHISTLEBLOWER

Firms cut costs and soldier safety lost out

M.K. Battery and its parent company, East Penn Manufacturing, declined requests for an interview after settling a $5.5 million case involving batteries for Humvee turrets ("Whistleblower gets a $990,000 reward," Sept. 17).

Think about this for a moment: U.S. soldiers were sent into combat with potentially defective batteries because a corporation considered reducing manufacturing costs more important than their lives.

After arguing with his bosses for more than a year, whistleblower David McIntosh contacted the Defense Department in April 2007. It apparently took our government seven more years to resolve the matter.

The manufacturer and its parent company were "pleased to resolve these claims … to demonstrate their commitment to supply the government with high quality batteries …" That's legalese for, "We aren't going to admit anything."

I suppose there are legal reasons M.K. Battery's actions aren't considered treason. But it sure feels like treason to me.

JEFF MOSES, Minneapolis
PUBLIC SCHOOLS

MPS blows the whistle on private school kids

In regards to the Sept. 17 article "Private school students booted from Minneapolis public school sports,"

I boil it down to this: The issue is not whether kids, whatever school they attend, should be able to participate in public school sports in 7th or 8th grade. The issue is not about the rules or whether MPS is following the right protocol relative to the state athletic league. The issue is not about what's fair or whose tax dollars are being spent where.

The issue is about MPS doing everything it can to make its schools stand out and rise to the top in an effort to attract more kids and make this city an even more desirable place to live and raise a family.

Letting the middle schoolers participate in high school sports can only help in bringing more kids into the MPS system. I'm not saying it's a giant act or will make all the difference in the world, but it's a constructive move. Little wins like this can only add up to more positive attributes and reasons to send a child to MPS.

KEN GOLDMAN, Minneapolis
about the writer

about the writer