In a recent "Item World," the Star Tribune's books editor, Laurie Hertzel, disapproves of Entertainment Weekly's choice of "Betsy-Tacy" to represent "the true spirit of Minnesota" for its "United States of Books." This classic series by Maud Hart Lovelace celebrates Minnesota history at the turn of the 20th century, lifelong friendship, supportive family, and strong girls and women with talent and ambition. Hertzel suggests novels by John Sandford instead. Many of Sandford's "thrillers" involve the coldblooded murder of helpless women described in gruesome detail. If that's Ms. Hertzel's preferred idea of the true spirit of Minnesota, I'd rather she moved to Wisconsin.
Theresa Alberti, Minneapolis
• • •
Lovelace was a nationally known historical writer when she began her successful series based on her childhood. While her childhood was admittedly idyllic, she did not compromise on her quality of writing or on research to ensure that the period was accurately portrayed. She dealt with issues that still resonate, such as discrimination against immigrants and women, rebellion, and religious conflict. The pseudointellectual rejection of writing that is not filled with dysfunction and cynicism is offensive and disappointing. Good writing is good writing. The Star Tribune should know it when it sees it.
Ann Wallace, Redmond, Wash.
• • •
On the surface level, the Betsy-Tacy books are about bucolic life in a small town in Minnesota. But Lovelace speaks to us about today's issues as perhaps the other Minnesota authors mentioned do not. If Hertzel had done her research, she would know that three of the Lovelace books take on the issue of Syrian immigration to the U.S. In one of her early books, Betsy goes to Little Syria, an impoverished part of Mankato, and befriends a young Syrian girl. "Emily of Deep Valley" is all about the founding of a settlement house for the Syrians in Mankato, and "The Trees Kneel at Christmas" is about a Syrian family in Brooklyn, and shares many traditions, customs and stories of being a Syrian immigrant to the U.S. Very relevant with today's headlines.
There are many other stories in the books where the characters take on issues of exclusion, depression and high school cliques, all set against a background of great love for Mankato and for Minnesota history. Minnesota is well-represented by Maud Hart Lovelace.
Lisa Mayotte, Hopkins
LAW AND CONSCIENCE
Life does get murky when ideals collide
Did anyone else notice the irony in the Sept. 9 letters to the editor?
One writer made the point that the law supersedes our actions when it comes to what is right or wrong. The county clerk in Kentucky needed to follow the law on issuing marriage licenses, not do what she thought was right or wrong.