Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey says Gov. Tim Walz delayed the National Guard order (front page, Aug. 4). Walz and his staff say that Frey was not specific enough in his first request for help. Then, when the governor's staff received a written communication, the staff said it also wasn't specific enough. Then when the mayor's office was specific through Police Chief Medaria Arradondo's request, the governor's staff said the request was beyond capabilities.
Initially, the governor sent 90 National Guard troops trained in riot control. Later he upped that number to 700. Ultimately, the total of troops sent was 3,500, but only the 700 were trained in riot control.
In an interview Monday, Arradondo said that he hoped the parties involved in communicating with one another "would work with the state to learn more about the Guard's deployment processes should they be needed in the future." He added: "There are a great deal of complexities, now I've learned."
From the outside looking in, this situation looks like a problem of terrible miscommunication exacerbated by the reality that bureaucracies don't move very nimbly. It also appears that all parties were operating under unrealistic expectations of one another.
It would be extremely valuable for all the parties involved in this folly to meet to approve a written communication plan that addresses who does what, when and how, and makes expectations crystal-clear in case cities once again need immediate help from the National Guard.
Steve Katz, Minnetonka
• • •
With the advantage of 2020 hindsight, I have to wonder why on May 25, when George Floyd was horrifically killed, our city and state leaders weren't thinking, "This could become a problem." Gov. Walz, Public Safety Commissioner John Harrington and National Guard Maj. Gen. Jon. Jensen could have contacted Mayor Frey and Chief Arradondo, asking, "How can we help?" or "How can we get prepared to help, just in case?"
At one of the early news conferences, the governor used the phrase "abject failure." Jensen said he needed a clear "mission" before the National Guard could respond; that sounded reasonable, but also very defensive. Shouldn't all of our leaders have helped one another to clarify the "mission" and assign the responsibilities of the various jurisdictions? What happened to "How can we help?"
Rochelle Eastman, Savage
• • •
I have been in general supportive of Gov. Walz. His leadership in the COVID-19 crisis and most other matters has been remarkable. That said, I am disappointed with his handling of the May riots. First, regardless of his 24 years of experience in the Minnesota National Guard, his delayed response to the request for National Guard help, ostensibly because the information given by Mayor Frey was not detailed enough or final enough, is simply unacceptable, given that the governor, not the mayor, has the ultimate authority over such deployments. But what really got me was the governor's subsequent finger-pointing and public criticism that the mayor's handling of the riot was a "failure." That was uncalled for. I believe Frey deserves the governor's apology for that. Let's then move on. We have so many pressing and challenging issues to address, and the two leaders need to unite.