I attended Saturday's very enlightening meeting of the Minnesota Republican Party State Central Committee in St. Cloud. The voting for a new chair to replace the retiring Keith Downey came down to a fourth ballot between Chris Fields, an African-American, and Jennifer Carnahan, a minority woman. Carnahan won.
In addition, the attendees voted unanimously to certify the Somali-Republican Group as an official affiliate of the Minnesota GOP, joining many other minority affiliates.
Looks like the labor union-controlled Minnesota DFL Party of "no" will be up against the Minnesota GOP's increasingly diverse "big tent." Should be a very interesting statewide election come 2018.
Bob Maginnis, Edina
• • •
My initial reaction to Jennifer Carnahan's election to the GOP chair of Minnesota was positive — until I got to her statement that the DFL is "going to have a really hard time calling us the party of racists and sexists. Look at who our party base just elected."
Full disclosure: I am a woman, a Korean adoptee, and a Democrat. It doesn't bother me that Ms. Carnahan is a Republican. What bothers me is the implied sentiment of her comment: "We're not racist and/or sexist, we just elected a minority woman!" Where have I heard that before? "I'm not racist, I have a black friend! I'm not sexist, I treat my mother/grandmother/sister with reverence and great respect!" To be clear, I'm not calling Ms. Carnahan racist or sexist. I'm calling her tone-deaf.
I also find it troubling that she is equating her minority identity (Asian-American/Korean adoptee) to minority groups more akin to contemporary GOP discrimination — black, Mexican, Arab, Muslim, etc. While of course not completely shielded from racism, Asian-American women enjoy a great amount of what is essentially white privilege (especially Korean adoptees raised in white families).
As Korean adoptees, we all have unique experiences. But we share a racial identity fraught with nuance and complexity unlike anyone else, and every adoptee I've ever met has found comfort in this common thread. I've also yet to meet one who would say their family or friends are immune from racism by association. I hope Ms. Carnahan takes a look at her statements as the new Republican Party chair of Minnesota, where we have the highest concentration of Korean adoptees in the U.S., and where young adoptees will be able to see themselves in her leadership role, and ask herself if being a token is something to which we should aspire.