Readers Write Jan. 14): Vikings, college degrees, hockey, Michele Bachmann, evangelicals, voter ID, Keystone pipeline

January 14, 2012 at 1:19AM
(Susan Hogan — Associated Press/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

VIKINGS STADIUM

Dome site offers lowest cost, least disruption

The infrastructure is in place. There will be no surprises in the soil testing.

It will cost less even if additional public money must be added to offset the extra expenses that the Vikings would have to pay, or revenue they would lose, at the University of Minnesota's TCF Stadium.

The construction would cause no disruption or congestion to the community during construction. Additionally, there is lots of available property around the Metrodome site.

The Basilica of St. Mary's site would be overpowered by this giant stadium. Construction would negatively impact the grandeur and ambiance that it now has.

The soils have not been tested. The stadium would be shoehorned into a very small area. The parking problems would be huge.

The Farmers Market area would cost the most, and disrupt a lot of businesses. The soil has not been tested to find out what additional costs might be needed to remove polluted soil or pay for the additional pilings that would be needed to build on the former Bassett Creek wetlands.

Building on the Farmers Market site would renew the quest to include the Caring and Sharing Hands site by condemning our property for the project before or after the stadium has been built.

We will oppose building on the Farmers Market site with all our strength because this would mean the closing of Caring and Sharing Hands and Mary's Place, which would deprive the community of a great resource.

MARY JO COPELAND, FOUNDER AND DIRECTOR, SHARING AND CARING HANDS

* * *

COLLEGE DEGREE

Whiny graduate needs an attitude adjustment

The higher-education system can be a web of problems. I get it. Most of us get it. Nathan Marks does not ("That college degree paid off -- for the schools, not for me," Jan. 10).

To take aim at colleges and universities about the inability to land jobs is not unusual. But rather than explaining why and how schools are robbing youth, Marks litters his opinion with whining complaints and a sense of entitlement.

The value of a diploma is meant to go beyond salary. While colleges and universities do a good (and arguably evil) job at up-selling and marketing life for soon-to-be college grads, jobs have never been guaranteed.

I agree that a staggering number of people are overqualified and underexperienced. But blaming schools is a simple answer to a complex problem.

Marks needs an attitude adjustment.

ASHLEY ADAM, MINNEAPOLIS

* * *

HOCKEY INJURIES

More than good intentions are needed

It's heartbreaking to hear of the permanent disabling of any athlete, especially at the youth level. Pledges and penalties will not bring back lives. It's time that hockey sideboards are cushioned to minimize the impact of direct, full-force checking from behind.

E.C. DEHMER, ST. PAUL

* * *

MICHELE BACHMANN

Despite her claims, she's no 'Iron Lady'

I read with interest the story in which U.S. Rep. Michele Bachmann was being compared to Margaret Thatcher, the former prime minister ("Will Iowans buy Bachmann as 'Iron Lady'?, Jan. 2).

Bachmann calling herself an 'Iron Lady' was like former Vice President Dan Quayle comparing himself to President John F. Kennedy. Neither Bachmann nor Quayle were close to being like these former leaders.

Should we draw up a list of better comparisons?

JOHN SORENSON, MANKATO, MINN.

* * *

GOD-TALK

Not all evangelicals are alike or conservative

The media needs to be more precise when using the word "evangelical." The religious right has hijacked a word that is sacred to me and all Christians. The word "evangelical" means "pertaining to the gospel." The word is not the exclusive property of one Christian group. I know. I'm a member of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America.

HILVIE OSTROW, MINNEAPOLIS

* * *

VOTER IDENTIFICATION

Here's a law we don't need in Minnesota

Minnesota Republicans are pushing for more rigorous voter identification, but their reasons aren't good. Data shows there's no widespread fraud problem and that our current voter identification rules are working.

The problem Republicans are claiming to fix is tiny. Analysis after analysis has shown that their proposed photo ID law would not have stopped the few convicted felons who wrongly voted in Minnesota, or that stopping these few voters would have changed any election outcome.

Further, they are not trumpeting or even supporting a bill to educate and notify felons of their voting rights (or lack thereof).

For a party that claims moral high ground for the "values "concept, playing so fast and loose with the truth to affect such a fundamental U.S. citizen's right is strange.

DAVE PAULSON, MINNETONKA

* * *

KEYSTONE PIPELINE

This project would create needed jobs

The Minnesota Chamber of Commerce strongly supports the Keystone XL pipeline project. The chamber, as the state's largest business advocacy organization, is committed to strengthening the business environment in Minnesota.

As part of this philosophy, the chamber is a member of the Partnership to Fuel America, an organization that's addressing economic development opportunities by ensuring that our energy resources for these opportunities are reliable, affordable and efficient.

Jobs created in energy development, such as Keystone XL, provide economic growth, generate tax revenue and spur regional growth.

In addition, the Keystone project would provide a safe, stable supply of petroleum, creating thousands of construction jobs while adhering to the most stringent environmental standards.

TONY KWILAS, ST. PAUL

* * *

GAY RIGHTS

People are making this harder than necessary

Some school districts still struggle with the fact that some students are gay ("No fast answers in neutrality policy debate," Jan. 11). If this presents a dilemma or creates a controversy, it's only because people aren't facing the facts.

The starting point for any honest conversation about the issue of gay rights is that sexual orientation isn't something we choose. If we acknowledge this truth and have the strength to let our humanity prevail over our dogma, there will be no question about what to do.

TODD HARVEY, NORTHFIELD, MINN.

about the writer

about the writer