It was with great dismay that I read that some lawmakers are proposing that Minnesota opt out of daylight saving time ("Changing clocks is getting tiresome," Jennifer Brooks column, March 14). Growing up in Chicago, my family had a lake cabin in far northeastern Indiana, a state that for decades did not switch its clocks. I know firsthand how disruptive being a "time outlier" can be when all surrounding states "spring ahead." Here are some examples.
Say you own a food distribution company in Minneapolis, and you have a contracted delivery time in Menomonie, Wis., at an assisted-living facility of 6 a.m. When they spring ahead, your driver will have to leave the warehouse at 3:45 in the morning instead of 4:45 to make the 1-hour-15-minute trip, (because it's already 4:45 in Wisconsin!). Oh, and you'd better get used to watching the Vikings-Bears game in Chicago at 11:30 a.m. on Sundays instead of 12:30. If you work at a branch office of a company based in Dallas, that mandatory, must-attend videoconference every Monday at 8 a.m. Central time now will start at 7 a.m. "Minnesota time" — but that's when you normally drop the kids off at day care! Minnesota will effectively be in the Mountain Time Zone but living daily in the Central Time Zone. Get the picture?
The legislators say they want to relieve Minnesotans from the one week of adjustment that invariably follows the switch to daylight saving time. Trust me, it isn't worth the 12 months of inconvenience and confusion that being a time outlier will bring.
Robert Adomaitis, Eden Prairie
• • •
State Sen. Mary Kiffmeyer's proposal to do away with daylight saving time might as well be called the Kiffmeyer Act to Eliminate Summer. I can't imagine going through summer and having it get dark one hour earlier. An earlier sunset would cut many activities short, especially toward the beginning and end of summer. Very few playing fields for kids in most cities have lights, for example, and these fields are often double-booked through the summer.
Imagine getting home from work, eating dinner, and then trying to get outside before it's too dark.
A dumb idea, Sen. Kiffmeyer!
Douglas Wobbema, Burnsville
• • •
Here is a letter I sent to our two U.S. senators regarding daylight saving time. Although I tried to use humor, I am very serious about this idea.
I understand there is discussion about getting rid of daylight saving time. Here is an idea I've had for a long time. In the spirit of compromise instead of moving forward or backward 60 minutes, just go 30 minutes and leave it. The people who want later sun in the summer will get some and the people who want early sun in the winter will get some. Everyone will get something but not everything they want — compromise. I'm sure "Big Clock" will raise a stink, but you can't make everyone happy. If you look at a world time clock, there are many places that are 30 minutes different, so there is precedent. Or in the words of Chief Justice John Roberts — stare decisis.