Thursday (The Mauer vs. Puckett comparison) edition: Wha' Happened?

Comparing two of the best players in Twins history and wondering if their reputations are borne out by their statistics.

September 6, 2012 at 9:02PM
Joe Mauer, left, and Kirby Puckett
Joe Mauer, left, and Kirby Puckett (Colleen Kelly/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
(The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Colleague Patrick Reusse had a couple of eye-opening tweets yesterday comparing Joe Mauer and Kirby Puckett at equal stages of their career.

Mauer turned 29 this season and is, of course, still that age now.

Puckett turned 29 in 1989 and was that age at seaon's end.

They have similar birthdays -- Puckett in March, Mauer in April -- and that's not where the similarities end.

Mauer's career numbers: 3,858 at-bats, .322 average, 244 doubles, 93 homers, 575 RBI, .467 slugging, .872 OPS, three batting titles, one MVP award.

Puckett's career numbers through 1989, when he was the same age as Mauer is now: 3,844 at-bats, .323 average, 197 doubles, 96 homers, 505 RBI, .469 slugging, .826 OPs, one batting title, no MVP awards. (Note: the original math tweeted out had Puck with 86 homers, but the total is 96).

Of note, of course: Puckett accumulated those stats in six quite full seasons, while Mauer has needed nine. That, however, means plenty of Mauer's at-bats came when he was years younger than Puck.

Also notable: Puckett averaged 18 homers and 97 RBI over the next six years -- which turned out to be the final six years of his career. It's not CRAZY to think Mauer will approach those numbers, but it seems more likely go guess Mauer (if healthy) will average more like 10-14 homers and 80-85 RBI the next six years -- not ridiculously far off, but still with less power.

ADVERTISEMENT

Additionally: The first six years for Puck include his first two, when he hit just four homers combined. Then again, he only hit 9 in 1989, when he won the batting title.

One more thing: It should be noted Mauer has played the vast majority of his career games at catcher, a much more physically demanding position than outfield.

All that said, it is interesting to see those numbers and note how similar the players have been to this stage of their careers. We tend to remember Puck as a blend of average and power, while we berate Mauer for only hitting for average. Yet the home run totals are nearly identical, as are the slugging percentage totals.

about the writer

about the writer

Michael Rand

Columnist / Reporter

Michael Rand is the Minnesota Star Tribune's Digital Sports Senior Writer and host/creator of the Daily Delivery podcast. In 25 years covering Minnesota sports at the Minnesota Star Tribune, he has seen just about everything (except, of course, a Vikings Super Bowl).

See Moreicon

More from Sports

See More
card image
Renée Jones Schneider/The Minnesota Star Tribune

The Gophers were outscored 5-0 at even strength and were outshot 46-21 by the Buckeyes.

card image
card image