Black Panther
The story: A warrior prince from an ancient, noble nation faces a life-or-death challenge to his birthright.
In its favor: A rousing story led by a powerhouse cast, with dazzling visuals and cultural heft. And has there ever been a prince more regal than Chadwick Boseman?
Then again: Ryan Coogler may have re-imagined the superhero movie, but it's still a superhero movie. Is the academy ready?
Our review: ★★★
BlacKkKlansman
The story: A black police officer finagles his way into the Ku Klux Klan in 1970s Colorado.
In its favor: A stranger-than-fiction tale that's Spike Lee at his most entertaining and (literally) hair-raising. The daring undercover operation feels genuinely treacherous and subversive.
Then again: The modern-day Charlottesville coda is pure Lee — a sledgehammer that feels unnecessary.
Our review: ★★★★