Will and should win:
Renée Zellweger
"Judy"
Role: Judy Garland in the dissolute last year of her life.
In her favor: Zellweger reins in her trademark squint in a remarkable metamorphosis that captures Garland's heartbreaking vulnerability, if not her spectacular voice. She even sells an over-the-top "Over the Rainbow." (Globes winner/S/B)
Then again: The film itself is maddeningly uneven, with ill-conceived flashbacks that distract from what we came to see.
The rest:
Cynthia Erivo
"Harriet"
Role: Araminta Ross, the woman who became slave liberator Harriet Tubman.
In her favor: Erivo is a quiet, steely, spiritual presence, tiny in stature but mighty in will. It's a tour de force, almost biblical achievement; finally, audiences saw the powerhouse who's better known for her prowess on the Broadway stage. (G/S)
Then again: She might have gotten lost in the trappings of a standard biopic.