Oscar 2021 predictions: Who will win for Best Actress?

Plus our take on the rest of the nominees

April 22, 2021 at 2:39PM
573503747
Carey Mulligan in “Promising Young Woman.” (Focus Features/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Will win:

Carey Mulligan

"Promising Young Woman"

Role: Cassie, who pretends to be drunk in bars to turn the tables on predatory men.

In her favor: The performance is revelatory, and Mulligan hit the interview circuit hard. She also has huge industry support for calling out a critic whose review she interpreted as saying she wasn't "hot enough" for the part.

Then again: People love or hate the button-pushing movie. Will the haters dismiss her work?

Should win:

Frances McDormand

"Nomadland"

Role: Fern, who moves into a van and hits the road.

In her favor: Not only did McDormand coproduce "Nomadland" and help shape her character, but the "Fargo" and "Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri" winner disappeared so completely into Fern that some of her co-stars, who play themselves, didn't know she was an actor.

Then again: The two-time winner will contend in 2022 as an upcoming Lady Macbeth.

The rest:

Viola Davis

"Ma Rainey's Black Bottom"

Role: Ma Rainey, a blues musician who boozes and applies lipstick as hard as she sings.

In her favor: It's a showy role, and like her win for "Fences," it originated in an August Wilson play. Although her supporting trophy was recent, she's due for a win in the best actress category.

Then again: The part doesn't have much range or screen time. At the 1988 Tony Awards, it was considered a supporting role.

Andra Day

"The United States vs. Billie Holiday"

Role: The legendary singer, hounded to her grave by the FBI.

In her favor: Oscar voters love a singer who crosses over into acting almost as much as they love a biopic; they nominated Diana Ross for playing the same character in "Lady Sings the Blues."

Then again: Backlashers don't like the limited view of Holiday, and debut performers usually lose.

Vanessa Kirby

"Pieces of a Woman"

Role: Martha, who is haunted by the death of her baby during a home delivery.

In her favor: The 20-minute childbirth scene is unlike anything else on screen this year. Two of the past four best actresses (Emma Stone, Olivia Colman) won at the Venice Film Festival, as did Kirby.

Then again: The movie is a mess, and because it stars currently canceled Shia LaBeouf, its awards campaign has been muted.

Missed the cut:

Yeri Han

"Minari"

Role: Monica, who is not sold on her family moving to the South to start a farm.

Why she had a chance: Last year's "Parasite" wins spotlighted South Korean artists, she's a star in her home country and she's in a movie that is universally beloved ...

Then again: ... by those who have taken the time to see it. Would some Oscar voters skip a gentle title in a foreign language without names or a zippy hook?

573503748
This image released by Netflix shows Chadwick Boseman, from left, Colman Domingo, Viola Davis, Michael Potts and Glynn Turman in “Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom.” On Friday, Feb. 26, Netflix released a study it commissioned from top academic researchers that shows the streaming giant is outpacing much of the film industry in the inclusivity of its original films and television series. (David Lee/Netflix via AP) (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
573503749
This image released by A24 shows Yeri Han, foreground, and Steven Yeun in a scene from “Minari.” (Josh Ethan Johnson/A24 via AP) (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
573503750
This image released by Netflix shows Shia LeBeouf, left, and Vanessa Kirby in a scene from “Pieces of a Woman.” Kirby was nominated for a Golden Globe for best actress in a motion picture drama on Wednesday, Feb. 3, 2021 for her role in the film. (Benjamin Loeb/Netflix via AP) (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
573503751
This image released by Searchlight Pictures shows Frances McDormand in a scene from the film “Nomadland.” The film won the award for best picture drama at the Golden Globe Awards on Sunday, Feb. 28, 2021. (Searchlight Pictures via AP) (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
573503752
This image released by Focus Features shows Carey Mulligan in a scene from the film “Promising Young Woman.” Mulligan was nominated for a Golden Globe for best actress in a motion picture drama on Wednesday, Feb. 3, 2021 for her role in the film. (Focus Features via AP) (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
573503753
Andra Day stars in “The United States vs. Billie Holiday.” (Takashi Seida/Paramount Pictures/TNS) (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

about the writer

Chris Hewitt

Critic / Editor

Interim books editor Chris Hewitt previously worked at the Pioneer Press in St. Paul, where he wrote about movies and theater.

See More