Opinion | All I wanted was a pill refill, but I fell into a rabbit hole

This is a part of life that worked better in the past.

September 26, 2025 at 10:59AM
"I’ve been around long enough to recall the good old days when getting a prescription filled was a snap," Mike Tighe writes. A recent attempt, however, was not so simple. ((Jackie Fortiér/KFF Health News/Tribune News Service)

Opinion editor’s note: Strib Voices publishes a mix of guest commentaries online and in print each day. To contribute, click here.

•••

I’m not old enough to remember when traveling snake-oil salesmen hawked miracle liniments out of carnival wagons, but I’ve been around long enough to recall the good old days when getting a prescription filled was a snap.

Back in the day, after a doctor scribbled an indecipherable prescription on a small piece of paper, you could stop at a drugstore on the way home, present it to a pharmacist whose superpowers included being able to decode the chicken-scratching and who would hand you a bottle of pills quicker than you could say, “Take two aspirin and call me in the morning.”

Now, digital commerce allows a doctor to message a drugstore with your prescription. But you dare not assume that you can pick up the meds on the way home, or the next day, or the next.

For example, I called three prescription renewals in to the robot voice at a pharmacy a couple of weeks ago because the refill deadline was approaching. After a couple of robotic messages from the pharmacy told me of delays for one reason or another, I finally was able to pick up the pills six days before the deadline.

When I got home, I discovered that one prescription was filled only partly, with a notation on the bottle that it included just “5 of 90 pills.” I waited a couple of days, assuming that the pharmacy would message me when the other 85 tablets arrived.

However, on the day of the refill deadline, paranoia spurred me to go to the store in person. The pharmacy worker told me the medicine had been on back order (I already had assumed that), but she would check to see if it had arrived. She came back and told me it still wasn’t in, adding, “But your prescription has expired.”

Stifling umbrage, I said politely (not only because I am a polite person but also because the store has a sign urging customers respect its employees), “It doesn’t expire until today, which is why I called this in two weeks ago, and I wanted to confirm that the prescription still would be valid.”

“That’s smart,” she replied, adding the caution, “You probably should have your doctor write a new prescription.”

Ba-da-bump.

Easy-peasy, you think? Not so fast — after all, this isn’t the good old days!

I called my primary doc’s clinic — hoping to tell a person my tale of woe and ask that person to send a digital refill message to the pharmacy. I was naive to think that I’d get a person instead of a robotic voice telling me to punch a number.

Of course, the disembodied voice old me that everybody was busy and urged me to request a callback, which I did. When my handheld computer that also serves as my phone rang, I answered and hit numbers as directed. Three times I called, and thrice the voice said it didn’t understand my answer before summarily canceling my calls.

The next morning, I got a message from my primary’s office saying it had OK’d a refill, even though my calls had been canceled.

Barely a half-hour later, the pharmacy left me a message saying the doctor had rejected my refill request.

By this time, I needed a drug to counteract my whiplash.

Good gawd! What if I desperately needed the prescription, if it were a matter of life or death? That’s the one point I lucked out on, because the prescription is only a water pill to make me pee more.

I’m old enough not to need a pill to pee more — all hours of the day and night. So the lack of a refill wasn’t going to kill me, but now I need something to recover from the stress.

I hope this rant doesn’t reflect poorly on all pharmacies, but I hesitate to name the offender, out of fear of retribution — other than to note that it begins with “W” and ends with a color.

Oh, for the days of snake-oil salesmen traveling the country in medicine wagons.

Mike Tighe, who lives in Shoreview, is a retired journalist who has worked at several newspapers and other outlets in the country, covering health, politics, religion and sundry other issues, as well as writing humor columns.

about the writer

about the writer

Mike Tighe

More from Commentaries

See More
card image
Leila Navidi/The Minnesota Star Tribune

In government leadership, young people need to be ready to accept the torch, but previous generations can’t slow down their leg, or delay the pass.

card image
card image