On the NFL: Eli Manning carves out a name for himself

When Eli Manning started out, there were doubts he would live up to his brother. With every playoff victory, he's quieted skeptics.

January 29, 2012 at 7:04AM
New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning will be playing in the Super Bowl against the New England Patriots.
Giants quarterback Eli Manning is 7-1 in his past eight postseason games. (Associated Press/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

It was around breakfast time in Miami on Feb. 5, 2007, when Peyton Manning was collecting his Cadillac as MVP of Super Bowl XLI.

A news conference had been arranged at the convention center, not far from where Manning's Colts had beaten the Bears about 10 hours earlier. As usual, Manning was entertaining, funny, even a tad punch-drunk from what appeared to have been a night of little to no sleep.

Toward the end of the news conference, a reporter from New York stood, grabbed a microphone and asked Manning if his little brother, Eli, also had what it took to ditch the dreaded can't-win-the-big-one tag.

"There is no doubt in my mind that Eli is a quarterback who will lead his team to a Super Bowl," older brother said. "Probably more than one."

It seemed like little more than the big-brotherly thing to say at the time. Eli, the Giants' slump-shouldered quarterback, was 0-2 in the postseason and the New York noose was tightening after back-to-back one-and-done playoff appearances.

The fifth anniversary of Peyton's Proclamation arrives next Sunday. Super Bowl Sunday. Needless to say, the tide has turned for the Giants, the Colts and Archie's offspring.

Little Eli has gone 7-1 in postseason games since the Peyton Proclamation. He has won a league-record five of them on the road and one at a neutral site when he matched big brother with a victory and an MVP in Super Bowl XLII.

Sunday, Eli will vie for a family-record second Super Bowl victory, moving ahead of Peyton (1-1). If he succeeds and becomes the 11th quarterback to win multiple Super Bowls, both victories will have come against Peyton's archrival, Tom Brady and the Patriots, in Indianapolis, where Peyton built his Hall-of-Fame career.

Peyton no doubt will be there, watching from a suite inside Lucas Oil Stadium, the house he essentially built but appears destined to be evicted from before a $28 million bonus he is due March 8. The Colts are rebuilding from a 2-14 debacle caused by a third neck surgery that sidelined Peyton all season. The likely scenario includes Stanford's Andrew Luck joining the Colts as the No. 1 overall pick and Peyton finishing his career elsewhere, perhaps in New York with the Jets.

"That would be interesting," Eli told reporters this week. "[It] would be unique. It would be fun."

It also would make for one heck of a Super Bowl XLVIII in New York in 2014.

Some have suggested a victory by the Giants next Sunday would move Eli past Peyton as the best quarterback in the history of the family tree. Eli 2, Peyton 1. Simple as that, or so they say.

That theory would have some merit if this were tennis rather than the ultimate team sport. It also would have some merit if there were a person alive who thinks a 1-0 edge in Super Bowl victories makes Trent Dilfer or Mark Rypien a better quarterback than Dan Marino.

Eli is an elite quarterback. No question anymore. But he still trails big bro in Pro Bowls (11-2), All-Pro honors (8-0), league MVPs (4-0), passer rating (94.9-82.1) and victories (150-76). Peyton also had his Hall of Fame résumé enhanced when one of the league's leading franchises collapsed the moment he was no longer able to prop it up.

Eli's postseason success story began four years ago. He won three consecutive road games and then stopped the Patriots from going 19-0 by throwing a Super Bowl-record two go-ahead fourth-quarter touchdown passes against Brady.

Earlier this season, the two met for the first time since that Super Bowl. Brady threw a go-ahead touchdown pass with 1 minute, 36 seconds left. Then Eli threw the game-winner with 15 seconds left.

Eli's composure also has been tested in the Giants' past four games. Facing elimination in each contest, Eli has completed 64.1 percent of his passes with 11 touchdowns, one interception and his three best passer ratings of the season.

After beating MVP favorite Aaron Rodgers in Green Bay, Eli went to San Francisco to face a 49ers team that had a league-high 38 takeaways. Despite wet conditions and a swarming defense that sacked him six times, Eli directed yet another upset while committing zero turnovers in a whopping 58 throws.

Not bad for a guy who created a buzz last summer when he had the nerve to say "yes" when an ESPN reporter asked him if he considered himself to be in the same class as Brady.

"I thought I gave an honest answer," Manning told reporters this week. "I didn't regret it at the time or think anything of it. Obviously it's been made into a big deal, but I can't control that. My job is to play the game. Your job is to talk and make up stories."

Mark Craig • mcraig@startribune.com

about the writer

about the writer

Mark Craig

Sports reporter

Mark Craig has covered the NFL nearly every year since Brett Favre was a rookie back in 1991. A sports writer since 1987, he is covering his 30th NFL season out of 37 years with the Canton (Ohio) Repository (1987-99) and the Star Tribune (1999-present).

See Moreicon

More from No Section

See More
card image