The worst sentence in NFL reporting is, "If the season ended today … ." But if the season ended today, the defending champion Seahawks would open the playoffs in Atlanta.
Seattle is 8-4 and looks more like the team that destroyed Peyton Manning and his record-setting offense in the Super Bowl. Atlanta is 4-7 and looks more like a team that might fire coach Mike Smith for going 0-7 outside of the NFC South.
The possibility of inviting Atlanta, New Orleans (4-7), Carolina (3-7-1) or, heck, even Tampa Bay (2-9) to the postseason conjures up visions of NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell heading for the nearest Dairy Queen to hand out plastic trophies to all 1,696 of his players while their parents clap and take photos.
Strangely, the possibility of a five-win NFC South champion won't affect Goodell's dogged determination to expand the playoffs in 2015. If that were the case, the Commish wouldn't have begun floating playoff expansion as a possibility not long after Seattle won the NFC West with a 7-9 record.
"I do believe [playoff expansion] will be approved for the 2015 season," Goodell said in March. "I think we want to see one more year of, will it impact the regular season in a positive way from a competitive standpoint? Will it create more excitement, more races toward the end of who's going to qualify for the playoffs?"
The widespread belief is the NFL will expand to a 14-team playoff field by adding a seventh seed in each conference next year. And if the season ended today, Goodell would be smiling because the seventh seeds right now are Baltimore (7-4) in the AFC and Dallas (8-4) in the NFC.
Worse yet for those who oppose playoff expansion is the fact that the current eighth, ninth and 10th seeds in the AFC are Pittsburgh (7-4), Cleveland (7-4) and a 6-5 Miami team that beat the current No. 1 seed Patriots by 13 points.
The current eighth seed in the NFC is San Francisco (7-5), but things drop off considerably from there with Chicago (5-7) as the ninth seed.