In a basement on the University of Chicago campus, senior Jackie Todd studied a photo of a topless female student in a blond wig, kneeling seductively on a bed.
"Something about her face here, it doesn't seem right," Todd said. "Her eyes look like they're focused on something else. It just doesn't work for me."
Seated at her computer, Todd clicked onto a photo of herself lying stark naked on the wood floor in an off-campus apartment.
"Ugh, we are not using that," she said. "I'm so pale."
Todd was in the final hours of layout and design for the provocatively named Vita Excolatur, a nude student magazine that returned to campus in recent weeks after a controversial end in 2007.
Nude photography and provocative posing are what made Vita a hit when it debuted on campus in 2004. But its real mission, Todd said, was to spark dialogue about sex and sexuality.
For an editor-in-chief trying to restore dignity to a risqué publication, the distinction between art and pornography is an important one.
"Anything can really be art, but it needs composition and it needs intent or a meaning behind it. It can't just be taking pictures of people having sex," Todd said. "The main thing for me is in intent. Did the photographer have a vision in their mind and did they execute it?"