In the early rounds of the 2009 MLB Draft, the Minnesota Twins went heavy on college pitchers. Their first four picks were pitchers from colleges. They followed those picks by selecting four college hitters in the next five rounds. Right now, lefty Tony Davis (12th round) is pitching in Ft. Myers already. Brad Stillings (7th round) is starting with the Beloit Snappers. The Snappers bullpen includes several 2009 college draftees including Matt Tone (14th round), Dakota Watts (16th round), Kane Holbrooks (21st round) and Peter Kennelly (38th round).
First round selection, Kyle Gibson, a right-hander from the University of Missouri, fell in to the Twins laps with the 22nd overall pick. He signed almost literally at the last minute and did not pitch in 2009. He has more than warranted his lofty pick and lofty prospect rankings with his early season performance. After going 4-1 with a 1.87 ERA in seven starts with the Ft. Myers Miracle, he was recently promoted to Double-A New Britain. He is 2-0 with a 1.26 ERA in his first two starts with the Rockcats.
2nd round pick Billy Bullock was taken from the University of Florida. He was only moved to the bullpen for the 2009 college season, but in doing so, he improved his velocity and his slider. He began this season as the closer for the Ft. Myers Miracle. He struggled early, but he has not allowed a run in his last 11 appearances dating back to April 24.
Those two are pitching well, but the other two Twins first-day draft picks have not been as productive. In his Minor Details blog last week, LaVelle E. Neal wrote that 3rd round pick, Ben Tootle, was sent to the Twin Cities from Beloit and they fear a torn ulnar ligament. If that's the case, he will need to have Tommy John surgery.
Recently, supplemental first round pick, Matt Bashore, underwent Tommy John surgery as well. The 46th overall pick last year from Indiana was sent to Elizabethton last year but pitched in just one inning of one game before being shut down.
Although Tommy John surgery will cost him the rest of the 2010 season, it certainly is not something that should end his career, or eliminate him from prospect status. What it does mean is that the Twins and Twins fans will need to be patient with him after his return.
There are several in the Twins organization that he can look to for advice and hope. Francisco Liriano and Pat Neshek are two guys who have returned from Tommy John surgery in the last couple of years. Jeff Manship, Brian Duensing and infielder Matt Macri all had Tommy John surgery in college. Carl Pavano has had several arm problems over the years and now is a very solid big league pitcher. Joe Nathan is rehabbing and recovering at the same time.
One player whose story is very similar to that of Matt Bashore's is Matt Fox. Fox was the Twins supplemental first round pick in 2004. That season at the University of Central Florida, where Drew Butera was his catcher, the righty went 14-2 with a 1.85 ERA in 17 starts. He struck out 135 and walked just 32 in 111.2 innings. The Twins took him with the 35th overall pick.
Like Bashore, Fox went to Elizabethton where he made a few appearances. Then he missed the entire 2005 season after having Tommy John surgery. The patience that he and the Twins have shown in his return has been impressive and, based on Fox's continual improvement and advancement, very successful.