RandBall: Ranking Vikings veteran quarterbacks from Jim McMahon to Carson Wentz

Try as they might to identify quarterbacks of the future, the Vikings are usually better with quarterbacks of the past.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
October 31, 2025 at 5:30PM
Jim McMahon (9) during his time with the Vikings in 1993. He's shown here with Cris Carter.
Jim McMahon (9) during his time with the Vikings in 1993. He's shown here with Cris Carter. (Bruce Bisping/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

(NOTE: Would you like to be alerted when I post new content? Sign up here to get one — and only one, I promise — email delivered to your inbox.)

On Sunday, the Vikings will hand back the keys to their future to young quarterback J.J. McCarthy.

The final 10 games of this season can still be defined by wins and losses, but the 3-4 Vikings are long shots to make the playoffs (especially if they can’t pull off an upset at Detroit). The rest of the year, more than anything, is an exercise in clarity and information.

Is McCarthy, who has only been healthy enough to play in two of 24 regular-season games since being drafted No. 10 overall in 2024 and was uneven at best during those two games, on track to be the Vikings’ quarterback for years to come?

Ben Goessling and I unpacked all that is at stake for the Vikings during Friday’s Daily Delivery podcast.

The beginning of that episode, though, was given to another question and an acknowledgment: The Vikings have tried to identify a quarterback of the future several times in the past three decades, but often they have turned back to (and had more success with) a quarterback of the past.

A colleague suggested that I rank these veterans, starting with Jim McMahon in 1993 and ending (for now) with Carson Wentz.

My methodology for choosing who made the cut and where they fell on the list was fairly subjective, but let’s take a spin through the ranking from top to bottom in today’s 10, er, 14 things to know today:

ADVERTISEMENT
  1. Brett Favre: I struggled with the top of the list more than the bottom, but in the end the magic of 2009 canceled out the calamity of 2010. Favre presided over the most whimsical, you-can’t-believe-it season of the past quarter-century, and he did it while turning 40.
    1. Randall Cunningham: He arguably had a better season than Favre in 1998, but he definitely had a better roster around him. Both veterans took the Vikings within a whisper of the Super Bowl.
      1. Sam Darnold: The more I think about what Darnold did last season in guiding the Vikings to a 14-3 record after McCarthy was drafted but then injured, the more impressive it is. He was a classic journeyman before he arrived, and now he’s an above-average NFL starter.
        1. Case Keenum: A journeyman who saved the Vikings in 2017 and took them to the NFC title game on the strength of the single greatest play in franchise history. There was an element of fortune to his game, but the results were undeniable.
          1. Warren Moon: He ended a run of QB shuffling with his arrival in 1994, giving the Vikings 2½ quality seasons before being injured in 1996 at age 40. His time in Minnesota was always going to be temporary because of his age, but Moon started more games for the Vikings (39) than any other QB on this list.
            1. Jeff George: Salvaged the 1999 season when Cunningham’s magic ran out, taking the Vikings back to the playoffs and giving them a bridge to Daunte Culpepper (their only long-term draft-and-develop success at QB since Tommy Kramer).
              1. Gus Frerotte: He went a very impressive 10-3 as a starter in two different stints with the Vikings in 2003 and 2008.
                1. Jim McMahon: He was on his fourth of six teams by the time he took over as the Vikings’ starter in 1993 at age 34, and his 8-4 record as a starter that year showed he still had value.
                  1. Carson Wentz: The numbers won’t overwhelm you, but he kept the Vikings’ 2025 season held together with duct tape, glue and a bulky brace on his left shoulder.
                    1. Matt Cassel: He was solid in 2013 as the Vikings otherwise fumbled around with Christian Ponder and Josh Freeman, then perfunctory in 2014 as the early starter before Teddy Bridgewater was ready.
                      1. Joshua Dobbs: I’ll always have a soft spot for the “Passtronaut,” even if the Vikings might have been better off tanking after Kirk Cousins was hurt in 2023.
                        1. Nick Mullens: A gunslinger as a backup quarterback is an odd mix, which was proven in that same 2023 season.
                          1. Donovan McNabb: He was brought in to be the bridge to Ponder in 2011, but he went just 1-5.
                            1. Kelly Holcomb: A desperate Vikings move in 2007 yielded predictable results. Holcomb went 0-3 in the midst of an 8-8 season. 
                              about the writer

                              about the writer

                              Michael Rand

                              Columnist / Reporter

                              Michael Rand is the Minnesota Star Tribune's Digital Sports Senior Writer and host/creator of the Daily Delivery podcast. In 25 years covering Minnesota sports at the Minnesota Star Tribune, he has seen just about everything (except, of course, a Vikings Super Bowl).

                              See Moreicon

                              More from Sports

                              See More
                              card image
                              Alex Kormann/The Minnesota Star Tribune

                              Kendall Coyne Schofield scored her league-high fifth goal of the season and the Frost won in their first game at Grand Casino Arena in nearly a month.

                              card image