The Minnesota Supreme Court will hear the case of a Monticello woman whose driver's license was revoked after she drove drunk to escape an abusive husband.
Jennifer Axelberg, 39, is challenging the revocation in connection with a spring 2011 incident near Mora, which Axelberg's attorney, Ryan Pacyga, argued fell under the state's "necessity defense." The necessity defense is used in emergencies where the damage that could result from obeying the law outweighs the harm caused by breaking it. In this case, he said, it should also apply to the state's implied consent law.
Axelberg had sought shelter in her car parked outside a Kanabec County family cabin following a fight with her husband. Both had been drinking. When her husbanmd jumped ont he car and pounded on the windshield so hard it cracked, she drove less than a mile to a tavern to get help. There, she was arrested on suspicion of drunken driving.
Axelberg, whose blood-alcohol level registered 0.18 percent, pleaded guilty to careless driving. She reconciled with her husband, Jason, who pleaded guilty to his charges and testified on her behalf at the revocation hearing. Although Axelberg's yearlong revocation period is up, Pacyga said they will appeal the case on principle.
Axelberg pleaded guilty to careless driving, but her license was revocked in a separate action. Although the driving offense is considered a criminal matter, the revocation is a civil matter under the implied consent law.
A District Court Judge and the Minnesota Court of Appeals both sided against Axelberg. District Judge Stoney HIljus reasoned that the the criminal-based necessity defense can't be used in a civil action, and that "the episode of domestic violence here is outweighed by the potential hazards (Axelberg) created for the public when she drove her vehicle while intoxicated."
The Appeals Court said in June that if the necessity defense is applicable, it is up to the Legislature to modify the statute to say so.
Oral arguments before the Supreme Court will likely take place in a few months.
![Mason Nadolney got his second COVID-19 vaccine shot during a mobile vaccine event at Chanhassen High School in July.](https://arc.stimg.co/startribunemedia/J7LEBWHZ57AFGZSTIR2WYOQJ3A.jpg?h=91&w=145&fit=crop&bg=999&crop=faces)
What to know about the latest COVID variants, Minnesota testing, vaccines
Sign up for Star Tribune newsletters
![Nearly a dozen collected Bachman's warblers lie in a specimen tray.](https://arc.stimg.co/startribunemedia/3KDGPJTGN5CRNG5PO5S5T35XUE.jpg?h=91&w=145&fit=crop&bg=999&crop=faces)
126 birds on list 'lost to science'
![Champlin Park volleyball player Carly Gilk posed for a photo by her mom, Shelley, when they arrived for the AMSA celebration at Target Field.](https://arc.stimg.co/startribunemedia/QPHJLQJMYJDLFMFTYKDONXWDQY.jpg?h=91&w=145&fit=crop&bg=999&crop=faces)