Girls hockey 2023-24: Meet the Dream Team, the metro's six best players, all with Division I plans

Two have committed to St. Thomas and one to the Gophers — and our list includes 15 more players who made the final Dream Team decision a difficult one.

November 29, 2023 at 2:18PM
Clockwise from top left: Minnetonka’s Lindzi Avar, Andover’s Mackenzie Jones, Andover’s Cailin Mumm and Stillwater’s Josie St. Martin are four first-teamers. The others are Ayla Puppe of Northfield and Dani Strom of Maple Grove. (Star Tribune photos/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Minnesota is deep with talent each year, but we will take our six against your six any time. Here's a high school girls hockey Dream Team for 2023-24, the best six players in the metro area, as selected by the Star Tribune's David La Vaque, and 15 others who made his decisions difficult:

Lindzi Avar, Minnetonka, senior forward

Started fast for the Skippers this season with 10 points (four goals, six assists) to tie for the team lead through four games against solid opponents. A versatile center who plays a 200-foot game, Avar is committed to Cornell. But first, she wants to lead loaded Minnetonka to a Class 2A state title.

Mackenzie Jones, Andover, junior defender

Not afraid to use her size (5-11) and strength to muscle opposing players in corners or in front of the Huskies' net. Not that her game is without offensive flair. Contributed nine goals and 14 assists last season. Gave a verbal commitment to Wisconsin.

Cailin Mumm, Andover, senior defender

One of three elite defenders propelling the Huskies this winter. Mumm, a captain, led Andover with four points (one goal and three assists) through three tough games. Represented the United States at the 2023 IIHF Under-18 Women's World Championship. Committed to St. Thomas.

Ayla Puppe, Northfield, senior forward

Big (5-8) and strong, Puppe is a textbook power forward. Hands, you ask? Her mitts are some of silkiest. Tallied 53 goals and 35 assists a season ago. The likely Ms. Hockey candidate started this season with nine goals and nine assists in five games. Committed to the Gophers.

Josie St. Martin, Stillwater, senior forward

Led the Ponies last season with 23 goals and 28 assists for 51 points. Stillwater stumbled out of the gate this season with a 1-2 record against a stacked schedule, but St. Martin remained dangerous with four goals and four assists. One of the state's fastest skaters, St. Martin is committed to Ohio State.

Dani Strom, Maple Grove, senior goaltender

Crimson coach Jim Koltes calls Strom, who committed to St. Thomas, "one of the best I have ever seen play the position." Won three of the Crimson's first three games this season by shutout and allowed just one goal overall. As a junior, she stopped 95% of shots faced and permitted just 1.36 goals per game.

Fifteen contenders

Grace Bickett, Orono, senior defender

Chloe Boreen, Hill-Murray, senior forward

Addie Bowlby, Lakeville North, senior forward

Kendra Distad, Minnetonka, senior forward

Hannah Halverson, Edina, senior forward

Carly Humphrey, Elk River/Zimmerman, senior defender

Josie Lang, Stillwater, senior defender

Courtney Little, Andover, junior defender

Zoe Lopez, Orono, junior forward

Lily McKenzie, Champlin Park/Coon Rapids, junior forward

Addy Mitchell, Eden Prairie. junior forward

Makayla Moran, Apple Valley, junior forward

Lily Pachl, South St. Paul, junior defense

Bella Shipley, Maple Grove, senior forward

Grace Zhan, Hill-Murray, senior goalie

about the writer

about the writer

David La Vaque

Reporter

David La Vaque is a high school sports reporter who has been the lead high school hockey writer for the Minnesota Star Tribune since 2010. He is co-author of “Tourney Time,” a book about the history of Minnesota’s boys hockey state tournament published in 2020 and updated in 2024.

See More

More from High Schools

card image

Six players plus head coach Garrett Raboin and assistant coach Ben Gordon are from Minnesota. The tournament’s games will be televised starting Monday.

card image
card image