Lizzie
⋆⋆⋆ out of four stars
Rated: R for grisly violence, nudity, a sexual scene.
Theaters: Edina, Oakdale Ultracinema, Rosedale, Showplace Icon.
There is something freeing about the savage killings in this distinctly feminist take on the notorious Lizzie Borden, history's most famous, if unproven, mom-and-pop slayer.
As played with fierce conviction by Chloë Sevigny (whose longtime fascination with Borden led her to commission the script), Lizzie is headstrong, wily and, possibly, an epileptic. A 32-year-old society spinster in one of Massachusetts' wealthiest families, she moves resolutely through the gloomy Borden household, every creak and groan contributing to its coffinlike atmosphere.
The arrival of Bridget (Kristen Stewart, wary and watchful), a deceptively timid Irish maid, arouses Lizzie's interest and her father's, too: twin longings that will help explain Lizzie's eventual violence and subvert a plot reeking with male power.
The murders are framed as a cathartic response to years of oppression by her miserly father (Jamey Sheridan) and loathed stepmother (Fiona Shaw). When Lizzie strips naked before hacking her two tormentors to slivers, her nudity isn't simply practical: It's the repudiation of a 19th-century wardrobe that controlled women's movements as thoroughly as men did.
"Lizzie" isn't perfect — the pacing flags — but Sevigny's intelligence and formidable control keep the melodrama grounded. Her empathy for Borden, whose fragile constitution belies a searing will, is palpable.