Girls of the Sun
⋆½ out of four stars
Not rated: In English and subtitled French, Kurdish and Arabic.
Theater: Edina.
In this team effort involving French, Swiss, Belgian and Georgian filmmakers, Emmanuelle Bercot plays Mathilde, a French reporter who wears an eyepatch after being wounded by shrapnel during a battle in Syria.
As the film opens, Mathilde is heading back to the front, this time in Northern Kurdistan. There, she falls in with a group of female Yazidi fighters, former captives of ISIS who have banded together to seek not just military victory but also moral retribution: According to the Islamic State's fundamentalist worldview, a jihadi who is killed by a woman doesn't get to paradise.
Although viewers may be apprehensive at the thought of a movie about the Middle East translated through the gaze of a white European proxy, once Mathilde gets to the front she meets Bahar, a former attorney who has the heart of a natural warrior. Portrayed with a combination of mournful gravitas and ferocity by Golshifteh Farahani, Bahar soon takes over the story, becoming an avatar of Kurdish self-determination and feminist catharsis.
Written and directed by French filmmaker Eva Husson and inspired by real-life fighters, this a film of admirable ambition but vexingly uneven execution. It too often feels formulaic and didactic, with Bahar and Mathilde's inner and external conflicts finally giving way to forced and obvious melodrama (which comes to a head in the film's maudlin, self-aggrandizing epilogue). The battle scenes feel like an unconvincing series of poses cadged from better war movies. The overall bludgeoning effect isn't helped by a musical score continually trying to signal that this is Something Very Important.
Ann Hornaday, Washington Post