Advertisement

Mark Craig's Sunday Insider: 49ers are the yin to Vikings' yang

Two teams that were 6-10 in 2010 have gone in completely opposite directions this season.

December 11, 2011 at 6:33AM
49ers quarterback Alex Smith
First-year 49ers coach Jim Harbaugh has done what no one else had been able to accomplish: bring out the best in underachieving quarterback Alex Smith. (Associated Press/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Advertisement

The Vikings and 49ers have lived their lives in parallel universes since coming out of the 4 1/2-month lockout with new coaching staffs that inherited 6-10 teams.

Under Jim Harbaugh, the 49ers are 10-2 and back in the playoffs for the first time since 2002. Under Leslie Frazier, the Vikings are 2-10 and off to their worst start in franchise history.

Harbaugh took a one-year leap of faith on a struggling quarterback and resurrected the career of Alex Smith. Frazier took a one-year leap on a struggling quarterback and might have ended the career of Donovan McNabb.

Harbaugh, an offensive-minded guy, inherited a young defense that leads the league in fewest points allowed (161). Frazier, a former Vikings defensive coordinator and interim coach for the final six games last season, inherited an aging defense that's 31st out of 32 teams in points allowed (320).

A week ago, the 49ers conjured memories of Joe Montana and Ronnie Lott when Smith posted a career-high 142.3 passer rating and the defense held the Rams to 157 yards in a 26-0 shutout. Meanwhile, the Vikings conjured memories of Les Steckel and 1984 when they were shredded through the air by Tim Tebow, of all people, in a loss to Denver. Now, with only four weeks left, the Vikings have to finish 2-2 just to climb past the 3-13 mark of Steckel's team from 27 years ago.

And, finally, a week ago, the 49ers secured $850 million in funding for a new stadium in Santa Clara, Calif. Meanwhile, the Vikings have no funding and no site heading into the final two games of their lease at the Metrodome.

The Gatorade shower that Harbaugh received near the end of last week's victory proved the lockout could be overcome, even by a coaching staff in its first full season. However, no two situations are the same in the NFL, especially when one team is in the NFC North (Vikings) and the other is in the NFC West (49ers).

So be careful when comparing Harbaugh and Frazier without adding some context. Their parallel universes include some opposite circumstances as well.

Advertisement

The Vikings play in the toughest division, with three teams that are 7-5 or better. The 49ers play in the weakest division, with three teams that are 5-7 or worse.

The Vikings have played seven games against teams that now have winning records. The 49ers have played four games against teams that now have winning records. They've gone 2-2 against those teams, including a 10-point loss while giving up nine sacks to Baltimore.

The Vikings have played teams with a combined record of 82-62. The 49ers have played teams with a combined record of 64-81.

But there is one thing the two teams have in common. Neither one can describe the season it has had.

Said Vikings defensive end Jared Allen: "I don't know what's happened."

Said 49ers nose tackle Isaac Sopoaga: "I can't even explain this joy."

Advertisement
about the writer

about the writer

Mark Craig

Sports reporter

Mark Craig has covered the NFL nearly every year since Brett Favre was a rookie back in 1991. A sports writer since 1987, he is covering his 30th NFL season out of 37 years with the Canton (Ohio) Repository (1987-99) and the Star Tribune (1999-present).

See Moreicon
Advertisement