Advertisement

Mailbag: How would you change the format of your favorite Minnesota prep state tourney?

Readers and Twitter followers weighing in on various sports mostly agreed on finding ways to get more of the best athletes and teams in a state tournament.

April 22, 2020 at 2:37PM
Khalid El-Amin led North High to the 1996 state boys' basketball title. Minnesota had a two-class system at the time and qualifying teams were placed in a single "Sweet 16" bracket.
Khalid El-Amin led North High to the 1996 state boys' basketball title. Minnesota had a two-class system at the time and qualifying teams were placed in a single "Sweet 16" bracket. (Howard Sinker/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
12/26/2018
DRAKE DOBBS Leads unbeaten Eden Prairie into Section 2 tournament. Paige Bueckers Hopkins and UConn-bound senior seek Class 4A title repeat.
(Paul Klauda/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

To our readers and Twitter followers: Your involvement in our Mailbag Monday is much appreciated. Since the biggest question concerning high school sports – Will there be a spring season this year? – cannot be answered at this time, we threw out a provocative question: If you could, how would you change the format of your favorite #mshsl state tournament(s)? You didn't disappoint. We broke your answers down by sport.

BASKETBALL

"Bring Back the Sweet 16 tournament for Basketball or a 64 team tournament.

Maybe even keep format but have the top 4 in all classes who win state play in a 4 team tournament to determine best in state overall." – Trent Witz @CoachTrentWitz

"Big-picture: AAAA hoops moves to a fully seeded 1-64 bracket. Small-picture: Get the random draw alllll the way outta here." – Jared Martinson @JaredNHR

"Switch the basketball tournaments to an NCAA-style 1-64 format by class. The current format sticks out like a sore thumb when a section final you call produces an 83-37 result, and everyone expected as much going in." – Mike Peden @TheMikePeden

FOOTBALL

"Seed the state football playoffs. No. 1 to No. 8. Neutral sites as equidistant as possible for both schools. If you wanna get crazy, then 1-16 after the section semifinals. Would eliminate the BOLD-Minneota or SMB-BSM situations we've seen recently." – Adam Rossow @AdamJRossow

Advertisement
Advertisement

"How about eliminating EVERY team making the football playoffs? You should earn a playoff spot." – Michael Boland @casperdog99

GOLF

The best amateur golf is match play. It should be a must at the State Tourney! Day 1: Quarterfinals & semifinals 18-hole match. All teams play 36 holes. Day 2: Championships, 3rd place, etc., 18-hole matches. Days 3 & 4- Individual Tourney, 18 holes a day. – Phill Drobnick @CoachPhill

HOCKEY

"No private schools in Class [1]A hockey tournament. Also...at the [2]A level, get rid of the current section process in hockey. Have a "North" and "South" section, rank the remaining 48 teams 1-48 and placed in predetermined "sections" at 6 rinks around the metro." – Tom Hoen @thoen88

Chris Slater (@cslater22) seconded Hoen's format: "You mean it doesn't make sense for Section 6 to have 5 teams better than the best team in Section 1?"

Advertisement

SOFTBALL

"I would like to see the softball mirror the basketball. 1 quarterfinal game on Thursday, 1 semifinal game on Friday (both W & L bracket), then play consolation & 3rd place on Friday & all 4 class championships at Jane Sage on Monday. Also move 4A & 3A tourney to a metro site." – Maple Grove softball @CoachKoltes

TRACK AND FIELD

"Track and Field to be more like wrestling: a true team event for the team championships and separate individual champions." – Ryan Gau @GoPher4Ever

WRESTLING

"Seeded 16 team wrestling tourney." – Aaron Knutson @knutsonaaron

Advertisement
Advertisement

"For wrestling, we need double elimination for the individual tournament!! Also, a two day team tournament so team finals can be Friday night and individual finals on Saturday night!" – Adam Thronson @thronson29

"Go to a True Team format, similar to track (no MSHSL team tournament. Fight me, folks.) State is a 3 class individual tournament. Split classes as so: biggest 32 and open, next 64, the rest. Any individual can opt up from A or AA to AAA, but not from A to AA. No opt-downs. Fully seeded. Top 8 byes. Double elimination." – Kyle Stevens

GENERAL THOUGHTS

"Seems like some sections are much tougher than others. Balance out the sections to make it possible that multiple teams from a section can advance. I think football from time to time does that?" – Patrick Donaghy @patdonaghy

"All sports play at professional venues or all at colleges. If some sports have to play at 3rd tier venues, where's the equality or respect?" – Rosemount lacrosse @RHS_IrishLax

"I'd like to explore the way Iowa does spring/summer sports. I believe baseball and softball are summer sports there and we have even worse spring weather than they do." – Tony @tonyz1986

Advertisement
Advertisement
about the writer

about the writer

David La Vaque

Reporter

David La Vaque is a high school sports reporter who has been the lead high school hockey writer for the Minnesota Star Tribune since 2010. He is co-author of “Tourney Time,” a book about the history of Minnesota’s boys hockey state tournament published in 2020 and updated in 2024.

See Moreicon

More from No Section

See More

Peek inside homes for sale in the Twin Cities area.

card image
Advertisement
Advertisement

To leave a comment, .

Advertisement