Perhaps this year we'll see a compromise: Sunday sales are permitted, but stores are closed on Tuesdays, because no one can play the "Oh we're having a last-minute dinner party" card on a Tuesday unless it's 1936 and you're Noel Coward.
Or: Grocery stores can sell wine on Sunday in exchange for giving up selling milk on Saturday.
I am sympathetic to the notion of making Sunday a day of rest. When I was growing up, nothing was open on Sunday except a few restaurants and a Stop 'n' Go convenience store, and its brazen flaunting of the norms made that seem disreputable. Only harlots buy milk on Sunday, we thought.
The mall was closed, so we had no choice but to go to Embers and stare at our coffee and think, "Man, we could be looking at black-light posters at Spencer Gifts, but, no, the government says we can't."
Somehow we occupied ourselves, and when the world opened up again on Monday, it gave the day a sense of newness and purpose.
But that horse has left the barn, run to the next county, died of old age and was sold for glue. Plus, the barn fell down and was replaced by a 24-hour gas station that sells that new scratch-card game, "Close the Barn Door!" Sunday will never be a day of rest again.