ROCHESTER'S MEMORIAL
It honors Americans
Where is Mark W. Powell coming from ("Rochester war memorial sets [faulty] facts in stone," March 26)? Since he lives outside of Washington, D.C., I can only assume he was being treated at the Mayo Clinic for Potomac Fever.
He claims errors abound on Rochester's Soldiers Field Veterans Memorial -- that there is a clear pattern of false superlatives rising from chauvinistic dishonesty and/ or gross ignorance.
He disputes the First Minnesota's decimation in a heroic Gettysburg charge as the war's highest regimental casualty rate, claiming the Confederate regiments suffered even worse. Excuse me, Mr. Powell, but I do believe that Minnesota was on the Union side in that conflict. He also questions, "America's 1918 success in the Meuse-Argonne is called World War I's "greatest" battle. For America's belated, comparatively limited fighting, perhaps. Greater battles and bloodbaths were many -- Marne, Tannenberg, Verdun, Somme, Ypres." And then he says D-Day's invasion and the Battle of the Bulge were not as big as what the Russians were doing.
America's 1918 success in the Meuse-Argonne is called World War I's "greatest" battle. For America's belated, comparatively limited fighting, perhaps. Greater battles and bloodbaths were many -- Marne, Tannenberg, Verdun, Somme, Ypres.
Mr. Powell, the Rochester memorial is meant to honor all who served in the U.S. military in war and peace -- not the Russia, French, Confederate or any other country's military.
Powell really offends when he wrote, "It stands part superb civic act, part gross embarrassment. Members of the memorial committee should be questioned about needlessly negligent execution of a great idea."
If he only knew the years that the committee worked developing this beautiful tribute to those who have served. I invite all to take the time to visit the memorial and judge for themselves.
RICHARD DISON, ROCHESTER