Letter of the Day (March 24): Real archaeology

Elevating a television 'sleuth' is a disservice to those who came before us.

March 21, 2014 at 10:59PM
History Channel In Season 2 of America Unearthed, host Scott Wolter continues his mission of using hard science and intuitive theories to explain the most mysterious artifacts and sites in America. Following many leads from viewers, Wolter explores everything from modern-day mysteries at the Denver Airport and pre-Columbian contact theories to tales of treasure in the Grand Canyon and legends involving storied artifacts like the Ark of the Covenant. What Wolter unearths continues to prove there
Host Scott Wolter in a scene from Season 2 of the cable television show “America Unearthed,” appearing on the H2 channel. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

I was disappointed by the profile of Scott Wolter ("History's sleuth," March 19). Real archaeology is far more interesting than the fantasies Wolter spins on his television show, "America Unearthed." Our ancestors — Native, European, African, or Asian — lived and died here; they loved and warred, built and destroyed, celebrated and mourned. Their story is excavated by archaeologists, handed down in oral traditions and written in family Bibles. This past shapes who we are today, as individuals and as a society. This past is important. It is a part of us.

We disrespect our ancestors and ourselves when we replace our real past with conspiracy theories and fakes. We don't need to pretend that the Aztecs built pyramids under our lakes. The real indigenous peoples of this nation built giant earthen mounds from Minnesota to Louisiana. You can visit some at the Indian Mounds Regional Park in St. Paul.

We don't need to pretend that the Knights Templar claimed North America before Columbus. There are many stories of adventure, determination and profound faith among the real European pioneers. It lessens their sacrifices to replace their history with fantasy.

The real past is fascinating. Don't demean it by pretending that fantastic pseudoscience is equal to archaeology.

Rebecca Dean, Morris, Minn.

The writer is an associate professor of anthropology at the University of Minnesota, Morris.

about the writer

about the writer