Letter of the Day (June 9): Catholic bishops

June 9, 2012 at 11:11PM
Bishops shelter themselves from the sun under umbrellas bearing the colors of the Vatican state during Pope Benedict XVI weekly general audience in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican, Wednesday, May 30, 2012. The Pontiff broke his silence over the scandal of leaked documents that has convulsed the Vatican, saying he was saddened by the betrayal but grateful to those aides who work faithfully and in silence to help him do his job. (AP Photo/Riccardo De Luca)
Bishops shelter themselves from the sun under umbrellas bearing the colors of the Vatican state during Pope Benedict XVI weekly general audience in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican, Wednesday, May 30, 2012. The Pontiff broke his silence over the scandal of leaked documents that has convulsed the Vatican, saying he was saddened by the betrayal but grateful to those aides who work faithfully and in silence to help him do his job. (AP Photo/Riccardo De Luca) (Colleen Kelly — AP/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

I wish commentary writer Susan Hogan and other reporters would take a moment and ask whether their prejudices are getting in the way of honest reporting on American bishops and Catholics ("Bishops seek religious liberty, but suppress a religion's shame," June 7). The question is whether Catholic charities, universities and other organizations should be forced to purchase contraceptives when Catholic theology teaches that the use of these substances is morally wrong. The Obama administration's "compromise" that insurers should provide these substances "for free" is an accounting trick. Where does the money for "free" contraceptives come from? From the fees and premiums paid by the organizations and their subscribers. There is no "conjured up" battle for religious liberty. The bishops are not "flexing their ecclesiastical muscles" in an attempt at misdirection. They are trying to point out that, once freedom of religion is denied to one group, the liberty of everyone is at stake.


CATHERINE WALKER, MINNEAPOLIS

about the writer

about the writer