Back in the last century, the late British writer Mirabel Osler wrote an essay that's cherished by gardeners the world over. In "A Gentle Plea for Chaos," she advised us to lighten up. Stop trying to control everything, she suggested. If you keep it up, you'll end up with a garden (and a life) that might look perfect to you but to others will come off as a bit, well, mediocre.
In Osler's view, the stray self-seeder that emerges for its own reasons has something to teach the other plants in the garden, the ones that mindlessly obey.
What brought her essay to mind is a recent conversation I had with a fellow baby boomer. I told him I was doing volunteer work for Bernie Sanders. He admired my "fire," he said in a world-weary tone that I did not entirely trust. While he shared my view that something must be done to restore "the old values," he'd decided he was too old for politics. He had no fire except for his 2-year-old grandson. By him, he was besotted.
I detected an unsettling smugness in his tone. A judgment. He was mocking me. It wasn't really about turning 60. He was, after all, still working. He found my activities offensive. Naive. How could I be so blind to the facts of human life? Hadn't I lived long enough to see how history repeats itself? Didn't I get it? It's not this or that law or politician or corporation that needs fixing. It's us. People were a bad idea. The sooner we're shuffled off the planet the better.
If that were true, I wondered, how do we account for the good things we do, the sacrifices for others, our magical inventions, our passion for redemption through art?
Why my generation rejected "the old values" to begin with is well-documented and still painful to think about, if you're a liberal. I was among those protesting the war in Vietnam and screaming bloody murder for equal rights for women and minorities back in 1968. I never stopped screaming, and not just because I'm a journalist. I chose to become a writer precisely because it amplified my voice above those whom I considered wrong, especially members of my own generation who seemed to be turning their backs on values of any kind as they joined the workforce, except the values of "family."
This was code for "familiar" — as in, I care only about people I know, and in particular people I'm related to. The diversity movement enabled people to put the demands of their kind before that of the whole. The melting pot gave way to the salad bowl. As family was redefined, the traditional extended family went out of style and alternative nuclear family units came in. Our growing sensitivity to the travails of the single-parent family and the gay/lesbian family spoke to the growing hegemony of the nuclear family and the weakening of communities that embraced all kinds. Public schools were resegregated and rural towns wiped off the map.
It's ironic that in the nuclear age, the nuclear family rocketed to importance even as outside-world issues like disarmament were shelved. Hadn't our triumph over the Soviets shown that cold wars could be won and hot wars could be contained (just as we'd contained the Red Menace)?