Legislature funds $6 million in updates to Dakota County's Byllesby Dam

Dakota County asked for funding last year to replace the dam's turbines but didn't get it.

June 19, 2017 at 1:33AM
Byllesby Dam’s innards date back to 1910, and its bearings and runners have been at work for most of the last century, past their recommended lifespan.
Byllesby Dam’s innards date back to 1910, and its bearings and runners have been at work for most of the last century, past their recommended lifespan. (Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

The innards of Byllesby Dam on the Cannon River were manufactured in 1910, when the average worker earned 22 cents an hour and William Taft was president. The dam's bearings and runners have been whirring for most of the last century, long past their recommended life span.

This year, Dakota County asked for — and got — $6 million from the Legislature to fund much-needed updates to the dam's turbines and powerhouse. In the process, the dam's hydropower production will nearly double, saving Dakota County taxpayers money on future dam maintenance.

Byllesby Dam has been a top-priority project for the County Board for several years. The county and the Department of Natural Resources have collectively spent $13 million in the past decade to repair its parts, mostly to satisfy federal requirements, said Josh Petersen, senior water resources engineer for Dakota County.

The rest of the dam is "up to snuff," Petersen said, but the turbines could go at any time.

"I always use the analogy [that] it's like driving a Model T," Petersen said. "Anybody can go out and buy a Model T Ford if you want to. … It's not going to be cheap and it's not going to be efficient."

The County Board sought $6 million in state funding last year but tabled the project when the bonding bill failed to pass.

This year, the Legislature allotted money to repair, rebuild or tear down six dams and make emergency fixes to several state-owned dams. The Byllesby project got the most money.

"We're thrilled to death," said Earl Benson, president of the Lake Byllesby Improvement Association. He said he's been living on Lake Byllesby "since I was two years old and I live on the lake now."

Benson said he's also excited about blueprints for Lake Byllesby Regional Park. At last week's County Board meeting, commissioners discussed a draft of the park's master plan, which includes more camping areas, trails and trailheads and access to the Cannon River below the dam.

Not exactly green energy

Byllesby Dam is designated as a "high hazard" by the federal government because if it fails, people would likely die and property damage would be extensive.

Northern States Power (now Xcel Energy) owned it until 1969, when Goodhue and Dakota counties bought it together. In 2009, Dakota County took it over.

A recent study determined that removing the dam was too costly, would deprive residents of the power it provides and might prompt a lawsuit from property owners because of diminished values, said Petersen, the water resources engineer.

Byllesby's new turbines will generate nearly twice the energy and cut maintenance costs. The excess power it produces can be sold, saving taxpayers money.

But dams come with "environmental baggage," said Luther Aadland, a natural resources consultant for the DNR. They block fish migration and their reservoirs emit methane, a greenhouse gas.

"The term 'green energy' probably doesn't fit real well with hydropower," Aadland said. "I think most people are not aware of [dams'] effects."

It will cost about $14 million to replace the turbines and revamp the powerhouse. The county will finance $8 million of that.

Erin Adler • 612-673-1781

The turbines in the more than 100 year old Byllesby Dam photographed on October 31, 2014 near Cannon Falls, Minn. At right is Dakota County water resources engineer Josh Petersen. ] RENEE JONES SCHNEIDER • reneejones@startribune.com
Dakota County water resources engineer Josh Petersen stood by the turbines in the more than 100-year-old Byllesby Dam near Cannon Falls, Minn. The Legislature allotted Byllesby the most money of its funded dam projects. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

Erin Adler

Reporter

Erin Adler is a suburban reporter covering Dakota and Scott counties for the Minnesota Star Tribune, working breaking news shifts on Sundays. She previously spent three years covering K-12 education in the south metro and five months covering Carver County.

See Moreicon