Souhan: Gophers football coach P.J. Fleck doesn’t need to overhype his program anymore

Fleck is known for his over-the-top promotion, but this year he’s focusing on pride and optimism.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
August 26, 2025 at 3:16AM
P.J. Fleck is entering his ninth season as coach of the Gophers football team. (Aaron Lavinsky/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

I recently attended a P.J. Fleck news conference, and something strange happened. Or didn’t happen.

I didn’t cringe.

Seriously. The Gophers football coach used the word “elite” sparingly. He spoke passionately and stayed on message, which is part of his job.

More important was what he didn’t say.

When Fleck arrived in Minnesota in 2017, and for many years since, he has often wanted to sell seemingly contradictory stories.

That with the right support he can make Gopher football great. And that because of the obvious limitations and competitive disadvantages facing the program, expectations should be kept in check.

I don’t blame him for setting those parameters, because, however floridly he would describe the reality of a Gopher football coach, he was correct. His job is to get the most he can out of this program, and he works in an inherently unfair industry.

Major League Baseball and college football are terribly run sports that thrive because fans can’t quit them.

ADVERTISEMENT

So last week, during his last full-length news conference before the season opener, Fleck raved about the state of his program, which isn’t surprising.

What was surprising was that he didn’t make any excuses. He didn’t downplay expectations.

And he could. He coaches a disadvantaged program in what might be the best conference in college football. He is expected to contend with teams that contend for national titles, and those teams have inherent advantages: more money, more tradition, better facilities, bigger stadiums.

While no one wants to hear him complain about his plight, he could make a fact-based argument for lowered expectations.

What I heard last week was an endearing blend of pride and optimism, which is justified by these developments:

  • In 2024, he and his staff landed the best recruit in Minnesota, Koi Perich. Perich looked like a star as a freshman, and as a sophomore he could star on both sides of the ball.
    • In 2025, Minnesota landed another top Minnesota prospect pursued by big-time programs around the country: Roman Voss of Jackson County Central, a versatile athlete who will probably play tight end.
      • Former Gophers continue to thrive in the NFL, with the latest example being the impressive training camp performance of rookie quarterback Max Brosmer with the Vikings.
        • In 2024, the Gophers finished ahead of traditional football powers USC, Washington, Nebraska and Wisconsin in the Big Ten.

          Heading into his ninth season, Fleck has talked about having “delusional” expectations and gunning for the college football playoffs, now that there will be 12 entrants — and likely more in the future.

          I’d rather have him publicly set high goals and fall short than depress expectations.

          “I’d want a head coach that wants to talk about it,” Fleck, 44, said of the playoffs. “Especially when there’s a lot better chance for a lot of other people to get in it than when there was only four.

          “As we keep evolving into the new world of college athletics, that becomes realistic for us. And if you look at what people are proposing, there’s been a lot of seasons we’ve been really close to it … you just want to continue to raise the level of expectations.“

          The ability to land Perich and Voss might hint at a new way to view NIL money, which, like any financial system in college football, is bound to favor the richer programs.

          What if top recruits like Perich and Voss were willing to sign with the Gophers because they would be more marketable in their home state than they would be at, say, Alabama, where all of the players are blue-chip recruits, and the fans may not know where Minnesota is located?

          The strangest aspect of Perich’s stay with the Gophers is that fans might want to hope it’s as short as possible. He’s going to become a pro. What might benefit the program the most is if he is able to spend the minimum amount of time at Minnesota, then become a first-round draft pick.

          That would bolster Fleck’s argument that his program can attract, develop and launch top talent, which is the best way to attract more top talent, which is the way to make dreams of a college football playoff appearance realistic.

          about the writer

          about the writer

          Jim Souhan

          Columnist

          Jim Souhan is a sports columnist for the Minnesota Star Tribune. He has worked at the paper since 1990, previously covering the Twins and Vikings.

          See Moreicon

          More from Gophers

          See More
          card image
          Samantha Hollingshead/Gophers athletics

          Luca Di Pasquo made 32 saves and the Gophers began their final series of 2025 with a conference road victory.

          card image
          card image