In Indy, many want the old quarterback back

Nothing like a quarterback issue that won't go away. (Not that Vikings fans would know anything about that.)

September 12, 2012 at 12:11PM
Denver Broncos quarterback Peyton Manning
Denver Broncos quarterback Peyton Manning (Associated Press - Ap/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Nothing like a quarterback issue that won't go away. Not that Vikings fans would know anything about that from the experiences of recent years, of course.

In Indianapolis, the combination of the Colts losing their opener with Andrew Luck and Peyton Manning's successful return to the field in Denver have combined to enable the second-, third- and fourth-guessers, some of whom you can expect to hear from in the stands when the Vikings play at Indianapolis on Sunday.

Indianapolis Star columnist Bob Kravitz, a supporter of the switch, is among the flash points for some of the rage.

From Kravitz' current column, which features some of the tweets and comments that have been directed at him and Colts owner Jim Irsay:

"I've got to think most people understand, three years from now, when Peyton is walking off into the sunset, Luck will be entering the prime of his career. Wouldn't you trade 12 to 15 years for the possibility of three, four years with a depleted Colts team?

"But football is designed for hysteria -- that's why we love it -- and no issue makes the locals more hysterical than anything involving Manning, Irsay and The Decision (Indianapolis Edition)."

Sort of like the way that no issue makes Minnesotans more hysterical, at present, than anything involving Joe Mauer and his contract. Different set of circumstances, same public displays of emotion.

By comparison, in following the Donovan McNabb experiment, Christian Ponder has it very, very easy.

ADVERTISEMENT
about the writer

about the writer

Howard Sinker

Digital Sports Editor

Howard Sinker is digital sports editor at startribune.com and curates the website's Sports Upload blog. He is also a senior instructor in Media and Cultural Studies at Macalester College in St. Paul.

See Moreicon

More from Sports

See More
card image
Photo by Matias J. Ocner/Tribune News Service

Fernando Mendoza lowered his pads into a defender, spun in a full circle, used his hand to keep his balance, then launched himself horizontally and reached the ball over the goal line — an Indiana touchdown and a ready-made poster pic for a title run straight from the movies.

card image
card image