How to get the most value out of your bathroom renovation

An outdated bath with leaky plumbing and yellowing grout is just the place to start and end the day — said no one, ever. If there's one room in the house where the glossy sheen of newness is appreciated, it's the bathroom, which is why bath remodels tend to offer a high return on investment.

Still, if getting the most money back out of your reno is your goal, it helps to think strategically before you schedule demo day. Herewith, tips from the experts.

Look at other bathroom remodels in your neighborhood

"One of the most important things to keep in mind for [return on investment] is the comps," says Sarabeth Asaff South, home expert for Fixr.com, a remodeling resource website. Her advice: Look to renovations done nearby for guidance (try scanning Zillow or Redfin for recent sales). For instance, a renovation in a high-end area might feature a stand-alone soaking tub and heated floors. "If you include those things in a non-luxury setting, someone might be happy to find them, but they won't necessarily want to pay more money for them," she says.

Prioritize cosmetic upgrades

Generally, spending on cosmetic improvements will yield more bang for your buck than a gut renovation, especially if you're planning to move in the near future. According to Zillow, a midrange bathroom remodel can yield a return of $1.71 for every dollar spent, especially if the bathroom is over 25 years old. Such a remodel might include updating the plumbing fixtures, tile and lighting.

Avoid changing the layout

Replace the tub with a spa shower

More homeowners are replacing tubs in the primary bath with larger, high-tech showers with multiple heads, says Shannon Kadwell of Anthony Wilder Design/Build in Cabin John, Md. "If a family has younger children or a pet, they still want to keep one tub in the house somewhere," she says, "but otherwise we are seeing the majority of tubs being switched out."

Install a vanity with storage

According to the Houzz 2022 bath trend survey, simple Shaker-style cabinet fronts are chosen by 51% of homeowners, followed by modern flat-panel styles, which appeal to 27% of homeowners. Turner is an advocate of vanity styles with built-in drawers underneath, which tend to pack in more storage than doors alone. For countertops, Kadwell recommends solid surface materials, such as quartz, that are easy to clean.

Replace the toilet

Choose a classic tile

"Tile is the driving force in the overall aesthetic of a bathroom, and people tend to love marble, especially in primary baths," says Nadia Subaran of Aidan Design in Silver Spring, Md. But marble can be pricey and start to look dingy if you aren't careful about sealing and maintaining it. Turner recommends sealing marble tile at least twice a year. For an alternative, Asaff South suggests a simple porcelain option such as a basket-weave pattern or penny tile. "It has a similar classic appeal and is easy to care for if you're a mop-and-go kind of person."

Replace the grout

On the subject of tile, one of the cheapest things you can do to add value to your bath is to refresh your grout, says Skylar Olsen, chief economist for Zillow. A word of caution: Turner says following instructions is key when reapplying grout, and if it's in the shower, the space must be completely dry for 48 hours before you start the job. Don't be tempted to use a grout pen in the shower, either. "They're a non-wet application," he says, adding that the pens are fine for quick touch-ups behind the vanity or along the baseboard, but they're not meant to be a permanent fix. "If you start down that road, you'll be constantly reapplying."

Lighting is key

Choose soothing colors

Experts almost always say homeowners prefer spalike shades in the bathroom, such as pale grays and blues. "White remains the most popular color for baths, but it tends to look a little stark, so people might add a pop of color whether it's an accent tile, or even just the wall color to give it a little personality," says Kadwell.

Coordinate metal finishes