Back in 2010, an airline passenger named John Tyner became a cult hero with a YouTube recording of a Transportation Safety Administration patdown. Mr. Tyner's voice could be heard protesting, "Don't touch my junk!"
The recording went viral because very few fliers sew bombs into their underwear. Citizens in a free country that have done nothing wrong often take offense at having the government invade their privacy with no evidence of wrongdoing.
It's helpful to think of the current voter identification debate in that context.
Republicans are the TSA.
One of the most basic rights of citizenship, the right to vote, is Americans' um, junk.
Colorado and Florida offer illuminating examples of this metaphor in action.
Both of those presidential swing states were targeted by Republicans in their national strategy of voter suppression. While neither state was able to pass strict voter identification laws, as happened in several other states, each state had a Republican secretary of state who set out to purge the voter rolls of potential noncitizen voters.
Colorado's Scott Gessler and Florida's Kurt Browning compared voting registration databases with driver's license databases. They found thousands of people who didn't have driver's licenses (and thus, according to their curious logic, might not be citizens) but were registered to vote. A high number of those people were minorities, particularly Latinos. They received letters suggesting that they'd have to prove they were real Americans.