Last season's merger of the Bloomington Jefferson and Bloomington Kennedy girls' hockey programs has resulted in an unusual quandary for coach Mark Stephan: Too many goalies.
The team went 16-9-1 while rotating three goalies — one from Kennedy, two from Jefferson — last year. All graduated, leaving the Jaguars with four potential goalies, none of whom had any varsity experience and all of whom are underclassmen.
So, in the interest of fairness, Stephan decided to make the competition for the position an open race.
"I've got a 10th-grader, two ninth-graders and an eighth-grader," he said. "I didn't think we were in a postion to take kids that young and say, 'You're the No. 1 goalie.' I said, 'I'm going to let you guys figure it out.' "
Now 10 games into the season, the Jaguars are 5-5 and the competition has yet to be decided. All four goalies — sophomore Brier Hagen, freshmen Emma Bonney and Hailey Stone and eighth-grader Mara McClain — have started at least two games and won at least one.
"No one has been great," Stephan said.
The glut of goalies has created a positive by-product, he said. Knowing their goalies are still unproven, the rest of the Jaguars have made a conscious effort to improve defensively. That paid dividends when they upset high-scoring Hopkins 4-3 on Saturday.
"The girls realized that they just need to play solid hockey in front [of the goalie]," Stephan said. "They said, 'Hey, let's have our goalies make fewer saves.' Saturday, we had five different players block shots against Hopkins. I think it was eight blocks overall. That kind of thing is difficult in girls' hockey.