Favre just needs to sit

Dungy: `I never listened to the player because they all say they can play ... even if they can't.'

October 28, 2010 at 7:49PM

Throughout this entire "will-he-or-won't-he-play" week, the one quote that stands out to me as the hardest to believe is this one by Brett Favre:

"I know I'll keep an open mind about it and be smart about it."

That was Favre pushing for input on whether he gets to extend his NFL record for starts to 292 Sunday at New England.

C'mon. Does anyone really expect Brett Favre to get to Sunday and look Brad Childress in the eye and go, "Sorry, Skip, just can't go on that broken ankle today."?

I was talking to Tony Dungy earlier today about another story I'm working on about Bill Belichick. But I asked him what he'd do in this situation if he were Brad Childress. He said:

"I don't think you worry about the streak or if guys want to play or not," Dungy said. "You look at the situation and you have to judge as a coach whether they're going to be effective. And Brett has shown in the past that he's a guy that's been able to play without a whole lot of practice. So Brad has some history in knowing how effective he can be.

"But that's your only decision as a head coach. I never had a hard-and-fast rule that you have to practice `X' amount days to play. And I never listened to the player because they all say they can play. Only if a guy says he can't play do you know it. Most of the time they all say they can play even if they can't. You have to make the decision. You have to watch them practice. You have to watch them warm up and make a decision of whether they're going to be productive for us or not."

The streak is legendary. And it will stay legendary if it ends at 291. And it should. The guy broke his ankle, for gosh sakes. Just start Tarvaris Jackson and hope that he's progressed after five years of being groomed in the same system by the same head coach, offensive coordinator and position coach.

I'd love to believe Favre when he says he'd keep an open mind about it and be smart about it, but isn't this the guy who has told us on more than one occasion that he shouldn't have played in 2008 when his torn biceps brought down the Jets' season and got coach Eric Mangini fired?

Childress has to make the tough decision and go with Jackson. And don't worry Brett, you'll still be the greatest iron man in sports history whether the number is 291 or 301.

about the writer

about the writer

Mark Craig

Sports reporter

Mark Craig has covered the NFL nearly every year since Brett Favre was a rookie back in 1991. A sports writer since 1987, he is covering his 30th NFL season out of 37 years with the Canton (Ohio) Repository (1987-99) and the Star Tribune (1999-present).

See Moreicon

More from No Section (Assign Gallery and Videos here)

See More

The man suspected of killing a Minnesota lawmaker and wounding another crawled to officers in surrender Sunday after they located him in the woods near his home, ending a massive, nearly two-day search that put the entire state on edge.