A civil suit filed by former University of Minnesota assistant men's basketball coach Jimmy Williams against the school and Athletic Director Joel Maturi has been dismissed, according to Hennepin County court documents.
Williams, an assistant under Bill Musselman and Jim Dutcher, claimed he quit his job as an assistant coach at Oklahoma State last April after he and current Gophers coach Tubby Smith reached a contract agreement for Williams to join the Gophers' staff.
Williams claimed that Maturi subsequently overruled the hiring because of NCAA violations that occurred on the Musselman and Dutcher staffs during Williams' employment. Williams was an assistant at Minnesota from 1971 through 1987 and served as interim head coach after Dutcher resigned following an alleged sexual assault during the 1985-86 season.
The suit claimed that the standard practice is for Division I head basketball coaches to hire their own staffs. Williams was seeking to be re-instated to the assistant job he claimed was offered him, plus monetary damages, including a claim of defamation against university officials.
"It's a complete victory for Tubby, Joel and the university," said Mark Rotenberg, university general counsel. "The court said it's important to provide deference to the university's employment decisions of this type, and found that there was no defamation."
The ruling by Judge Regina M. Chu also noted that District Court was not the proper venue for the case, Rotenberg said. It recommended that Williams should have filed a grievance under the university's internal procedures, and if he was unhappy with that result he should have taken his case to the Minnesota Court of Appeals.
Rotenberg said he was hopeful Chu's ruling "puts this case to rest," but acknowledged an appeal was possible.
Williams' attorney, Dick Hunegs, could not be reached for comment.