Diver finds $7,000 ring in Lake Minnetonka

An engagement ring lost during a July 4 boat outing on Lake Minnetonka has been returned to the finger of its rightful owner.

July 15, 2010 at 4:21AM
Adam Segar and Sara Stocco thought Sara's engagement ring was lost forever in Lake Minnetonka, but diver Denny Geffre thought otherwise.
AVID BREWSTER • dbrewster@startribune.com Adam Segar and Sara Stocco thought Sara’s engagement ring was lost forever in Lake Minnetonka, but diver Denny Geffre thought otherwise. (Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Just a month after her boyfriend slipped it on her finger, Sara Stocco's shining engagement ring went from hand, to mouth, to the bottom of Lake Minnetonka in a matter of moments.

Boating on July 4 with her fiancé, Adam Segar, and drifting about 50 feet offshore with other boater friends, Stocco went into a frenzy as the ring, which she had removed to apply sunscreen, fell into the 4 1/2-feet-deep water and nestled somewhere into the sandy bottom.

Several friends jumped in, frantically diving to the bottom but mostly making the water murkier. Segar stood stunned. Stocco's gut reaction? Look for goggles.

"It was chaotic. I just remember thinking, 'Oh, my gosh, I just lost my ring that I've had a little over a month,'" Stocco said of the .89-carat diamond ring from Tiffany's, worth $7,000.

Word of her plight quickly spread to those on nearby boats, including the son of area scuba diver Denny Geffre. The son called Dad.

"I find cars and snowmobiles or boats that sink, anything that's just lost," said Geffre, 60, who arrived on the scene 30 minutes later, scuba gear and metal detector at the ready. "There aren't that many cars that actually fall through the lake, but there's probably a lot of rings."

Stocco, 27, a St. Paul high school teacher, had slipped hers off and put it in her mouth so she could put sunscreen on her fiancé.

"My friends were all telling me that I shouldn't put lotion on or shower while wearing it, so it wouldn't get dirty, and then it was gone. So ironic," she said.

The ring slipped from her mouth, bounced off the floor of the boat and into the water.

Segar, who was sober and driving the boat, said he saw the whole thing in slow motion.

"We were like on the drunkest area for the 4th of July, and I think I was the only one in the position to stay calm," said the 28-year-old accountant.

When Geffre arrived, he saw too many boats and ruled out searching that day. He ordered some people to get big rocks from shore and bring them out to mark where to later begin his search.

In the next week, Geffre made several dives, spending a total of 14 hours searching. Segar kept checking in, hoping for the best.

Finally, on the day that Segar intended to call off the search and get a new ring with insurance money, Geffre found his prize buried in 3 inches of sand 25 feet from where it was lost.

Geffre, co-owner of a Long Lake flooring business, spends a couple of days a week scuba diving to relax. For his efforts, he received a $750 award.

"I have a lot of experience and a lot of patience. You just keep finding junk and junk, but if you stay long enough, the metal detector will pick it up," said Geffre.

The happy couple? The wedding is set for next July.

The ring? Stocco said she hasn't taken it off since Segar placed it on her finger, once again.

Hannah Gruber • 612-673-4864

Denny Geffre
Denny Geffre (Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

HANNAH GRUBER, Star Tribune