Counterpoint: The South may have lost the war, but its culture won

Americans accepted ideas pushed by books and media that supported racism.

June 23, 2020 at 10:41PM
FILE - In this Dec. 19, 1939 file photo, a crowd gathers outside the Astor Theater on Broadway during the premiere of "Gone With the Wind" in New York. HBO Max has temporarily removed "Gone With the Wind" from its streaming library in order to add historical context to the 1939 film long criticized for romanticizing slavery and the Civil War-era South. (AP Photo)
On Dec. 19, 1939, a crowd gathers outside the Astor Theater on Broadway during the premiere of “Gone With the Wind” in New York. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

The South may have lost the Civil War, but when it came to public opinion, it won the culture war well into the 20th century ("With malice toward all, with charity for none," D.J. Tice column, June 21).

Most Americans, including historians, accepted the idea that the South had fought nobly, not to retain slavery but, rather, to uphold "states' rights."

The widespread acceptance of this idea fueled the "Lost Cause" myth. That myth, in turn, led to veterans of both Northern and Southern armies coming together for national reconciliation late in the 19th and into the 20th centuries, at the expense of African-Americans.

So-called "scientific racism" in books, encyclopedias and magazines upheld the idea that African-Americans were inferior to white Americans. Thus, white southerners needed to control them through Jim Crow segregation.

In 1915, President Woodrow Wilson announced that D.W. Griffith's "Birth of a Nation" was true history. In the 1930s, Margaret Mitchell's "Gone with the Wind" not only became a bestseller but a huge box office hit as a movie. In the 1950s, Disney's "Song of the South" glorified plantation life in "the wonderful time before the war."

All of these publications and media events perpetuated racist ideas.

Given this long infusion of racist thinking, removing offensive statues, flags and monuments is necessary. Failure to do so indicates our acceptance of the part they still play in American life.

Bias and racism still poison white relations with African-Americans. They deserve dignity and respect.

Shirley Leckie Reed, of St. Paul, is professor emerita, University of Central Florida.

about the writer

about the writer

Shirley Leckie Reed

More from Commentaries

See More
card image
Elizabeth Flores/The Minnesota Star Tribune

There’s always been a quiet tension between Black people of different backgrounds. But these communities are merging under pressure.

card image
card image