Counterpoint: At the library, there's more than one kind of diversity

It should be a place of learning, not indoctrination.

June 29, 2021 at 10:30PM
Libraries, the writer argues, are supported by taxpayer dollars and should not be in the business of promoting certain viewpoints over others. (iStock/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

In "Hey, Anoka County, listen and listen good," (June 27) columnist Jennifer Brooks writes about the need for conversations. Conversations about important subjects like George Floyd's murder, the Derek Chauvin sentencing, the Black Lives Matter movement, bigotry, gun violence, diversity. She declares that "our differences have left us fractured and furious. Unable to unite against injustice."

Brooks angrily points to a memo from the management of the Anoka County Library, which apparently doesn't present diversity in way that suits her tastes. Brooks belittles the library leaders for encouraging "diversity on a broader spectrum" instead of hanging posters that celebrate Gay Pride or promote the Black Lives Matter organization.

For Brooks, a stance that believes libraries "are meant to be content neutral …" and "a nonpolitical place where patrons can access reading material, and everyone feels welcome and safe" (as an e-mail from Anoka County staff explains) isn't good enough.

For Brooks, "not choosing sides is a choice."

Libraries are established to educate minds. Most libraries contain many books, all designed to promote education, entertainment, ideas and literary appreciation. They offer fiction, nonfiction, books for children, DIY instruction manuals, biographies — books that contain various theories and philosophies written by authors who hold various worldviews.

In this time of unrest and division, what is wrong with providing a neutral space for readers to gather? Public libraries supported by taxpayer dollars should not be in the business of promoting certain viewpoints over others.

As an Anoka County resident, I enjoy going to the county library. I use it often. I also value great conversations, including with those who hold different viewpoints.

I was horrified by the murder of George Floyd. I don't believe anyone should be discriminated against or treated unkindly. The attack on the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6 was unconscionable.

Did I mention, by the way, that I am a vaccinated, mask-wearing, independent conservative Evangelical who has never voted for Donald Trump? (Or Joe Biden, for that matter.)

A library is a place of learning. Its walls shouldn't be covered with posters promoting a particular political viewpoint or worldview. Like a public school, a public library should not be used to shape or change someone's personal morality or religious views.

Brooks has shamed the Anoka Public Library system for not espousing one viewpoint over another and mocks its goal of being a neutral space that welcomes all. America is a pluralistic society: True conversation and exchange of ideas cannot occur between people who do not respect each other and are unwilling to listen to other opinions. For Brooks, her words suggest, there is only one possible viewpoint, only one acceptable belief system.

Such a worldview promotes a chilling groupthink mentality that despises those who dare to object and belittles others who hold opposing opinions.

A "conversation" about worldviews might be a good place to start.

Patricia Thomson lives in Ham Lake.

about the writer

about the writer

Patricia Thomson

More from Commentaries

See More
The family of Harper Moyski, far right, poses with their Christmas tree at the Annunciation tree lot in December 2024.
Provided by Jackie Flavin

She was one of two children killed in the Annunciation shooting in August. In the darkness of this winter, here’s what gives me hope.

card image
card image