Ryan Seacrest, Steven Tyler, Jennifer Lopez, Randy Jackson
Based on selected clips I've seen of the new "American Idol," which returns without SImon Cowell on Jan. 19, and talking with new judges Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler this morning, the country's no. 1 show had a tough road ahead. That's because producers and talent are determined to present a kinder, gentler "Idol," despite the fact that lots of fans tune in to the audition portion of the show to watch the insults fly.
All those associated with the show's greatest appeal is finding the country's greatest singer. I disagree. I always felt the chemistry and tension between the judges is the most important element, which is why Simon Cowell was so important to its success.
Not to say that JLo and Tyler don't have their appeal. Both were down-to-earth, charming - but not drop-dead hilarious, like Cowell was on purpose and Paula Abdul was by accident. Ryan Seacrest nailed it when he the show works best when it resembles a circus. The problem: I'm not sure the show has a proper clown.
One weird revelation: Tyler said that part of his decision to do the show with JLo had to do with how impressed he was with "The Back Up Plan," offering the only positive review the film has gotten.
Other weird moment: A reporter asks JLo what it's like to be a Latino on "Idol." "I don't know how it would feel to be anything else," JLo replied. Good answer, but Simon would have knocked that silly ??? out of the park.
And finally...a reporter addresses Jennifer Lopez as Miss Lo. Love it.
